What is this mortal insect that has stung the youth of
Werther? Mistake it not, it is the spirit of doubt, the
spirit of the eighteenth century; and it is not Werther only
that the insect has stung--it is Goethe himself. Goethe
belongs to the eighteenth century; he is its disciple, its
heir; he is, like it, the sceptic, but he is also the poet.
It is this which conceals his universal doubt. Besides, as
he perceived, with that admirable tact which accompanies his
genius, that his scepticism would injure his poetry, he has
laboured to correct its influence, and, for this purpose,
has called to his aid all the resources of art and science.
He has adored nature, he has been a pantheist, he has distributed
God everywhere, to compensate for not having him in his own heart;
he has adored Greece, and rendered a sort of worship to beauty
such as the Greeks conceived it, and endeavoured to find an
enthusiasm in the arts; he has adored the south, and sung the Land
of the orange grove, because the south is the region of strong
faiths, and is repugnant to scepticism; he has adored the middle
ages, because they were ignorant of doubt, everywhere he has
sought to cure the wound of that insect which had stung his youth.
But no; his scepticism pierces through all his enthusiasm, and the
very variety of his inspirations proves his indifference. He is
neither philosopher, nor devotee, nor Christian, nor pagan, nor
courtier, nor citizen, nor of times ancient or modern, nor of the
north, nor of the south-or rather, he is all these at once. He is
the echo of nature, he repeats to us all her harmonies; but he
fails to add that utterance, which unites so well with the
harmonies of the world the utterance of his own heart. Ask of
Goethe to represent man and nature in all their variety and
extent, and he will do it. There is one thing you must not ask of
him--himself. This _self_ fails in Goethe; not the self which
knows it is a great poet, and will to be one; but that other self,
which has a thought, a principle to contend for, which, in
short, believes in something. It is there the insect stung; both
in Goethe and in Werther.
After discussing the character of modern French literature, there
remains the important question to determine, how far the state of
literature represents the state of society--how far the one is a
faithful picture of the other. Upon this subject M. Girardin concludes
his volume with some excellent remarks; but here we must also conclude
our notice of this interesting work.
LORD ELDON.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account