Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 57, No. 355, May 1845Various
Philosophy
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 57, No. 355, May 1845
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"When an ancient word, for its sound and significancy, deserves to be
revived, I have that reasonable veneration for antiquity to restore
it. All beyond this is superstition. Words are not like landmarks, so
sacred as never to be removed. Customs are changed, and even statutes
are silently repealed, when the reason ceases for which they were
enacted. As for the other part of the argument--that his thoughts
will lose of their original beauty by the innovation of words--in the
first place, not only their beauty but their being is lost, where
they are no longer understood, which is the present case. I grant
that something must be lost in all transfusion--that is, in all
translations; but the sense will remain, which would otherwise be
lost, or at least be maimed, when it is scarce intelligible, and that
but to a few. How few are there who can read Chaucer, so as to
understand him perfectly! And if imperfectly, then with less profit
and no pleasure. It is not for the use of some old Saxon friends that
I have taken these pains with him--let them neglect my version,
because they have no need of it. I made it for their sakes who
understand sense and poetry as well as they, when that poetry and
sense is put into words which they understand. I will go further, and
dare to add, that what beauties I lose in some places, I give to
others which had them not originally. But in this I may be partial to
myself; let the reader judge, and I submit to his decision. Yet I
think I have just occasion to complain of them, who, because they
understand Chaucer, would deprive the greater part of their
countrymen of the same advantage, and hoard him up as misers do their
granddam gold, only to look on it themselves, and hinder others from
making use of it. In sum, I seriously protest, that no man ever had,
or can have, a greater veneration for Chaucer than myself. I have
translated some part of his works, only that I might perpetuate his
memory, or at least refresh it, amongst my countrymen. If I have
altered him any where for the better, I must at the same time
acknowledge, that I could have done nothing without him. _Facile est
inventis addere_ is no great commendation; and I am not so vain to
think I have deserved a greater."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account