Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 58, Number 360, October 1845Various
Philosophy
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 58, Number 360, October 1845
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"I am sorry that the resolution I have formed, of frankly speaking
my mind throughout this work, obliges me to express myself as I
do here and elsewhere with such an apparent want of modesty; but
were I to adopt, with regard to this discovery, and the knowledge
we have hitherto had of the science of grammar, what is
understood by a more becoming and humble tone, I should, by doing
so, lose in truth what I might gain by affected modesty, since I
should not only be speaking falsely, but be leading the reader
into error by concealing from him my real opinion, which I should
by no means do. And if while it be allowed, as I am sure it must,
that though I do well to speak as I think, it be observed that
this is not a reason why I should think as I do--that is, so
presumptuously--I beg to reply, that if I had never _thought so_,
this discovery had never been attempted, and much less made; for
notwithstanding what the world may say about the modesty of
certain great men, I do in my heart believe that such modesty has
been ever affected, and that it is wholly impossible that any
thing great may be undertaken or achieved, but where there is at
bottom great presumption, which is, after all, nothing more than
a consciousness of one's own strength."
This is all right, and no apology was necessary. Why should a man be
modest, who, in the six thousandth year of the creation, has found
out, for the first time, the science of languages? Though entirely
devoid of originality ourselves, we can sympathize with the proud
exultation of those who have produced a new and "glorious birth." From
the cackling of the hen when she has laid an egg, to the [Greek:
heurecha] of Archimedes when he discovered hydrostatics, we see the
instinctive impulse under which those who have brought to light a
great result, are constrained to proclaim it aloud; and we should be
thankful when the mighty inventor can refrain from rushing out, in
native nudity, into the public way.
The discoverer of the science of languages, however, does not come
forth upon us, like Archimedes, in a state of dishabille. Attired in
the same fashionable garb, rejoicing in the same paper and type, and
issuing from the shelves of the same respectable publishers, Mr
Kavanagh's two goodly octavos may fitly range, as far as exterior is
concerned, with the collected productions of Jeffrey and Macaulay, who
will no doubt feel honoured by such good company. The fly-leaf at the
beginning of the work warns all pirates and poachers "that it is
private property, protected by the late Copyright Act;" and a foot-note
seems to inform us that a French edition is simultaneously to appear
in Paris. Who could doubt that such mighty notes of preparation were
to usher in some _magnum opus_, worthy of the expectations thus
excited?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account