Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 398, December 1848Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 64, No. 398, December 1848
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"In pursuing the analogies here I considered, it is
necessary to compare mere art with art--the form, as such,
of the one, with the form of the other. Thus, in comparing
sculpture and poetry together, the parallel conditions are
to be sought in the strictly corresponding departments. As
sculpture, in reference to nature, (to repeat an observation
before made,) gives substance for substance, so poetry gives
words for words. Accordingly, the form of poetry is by
agreement or convention (similar in principle to that which
dictates the conditions of sculpture) effectually
distinguished from the form of ordinary language. And it
will now be seen that the limitations of poetry, in such
outward characteristics, are more definite and more
comprehensive than those of sculpture; for whereas the
material of marble may sometimes coincide literally with
that of substances in nature, the form of poetry never can
entirely coincide with that of ordinary language. This
greater liability of sculpture to be confounded with reality
certainly adds to its difficulty, since the doubtful cases,
which may be left to the taste of the sculptor, are often
settled by an immutable rule for the poet."
Whoever would desire a knowledge of the original causes of the
differences of alto, basso, and mezzo relievo, should read the
admirable treatise on the subject. They are not to be confounded as
arising from the same conditions, and subject to the same rules. The
differences of position and light, by their distinct requirements,
separate the three styles of relievo, the alto, basso, and mezzo. It
is not, as many suppose, that the basso, the lower relief, is less
finished than the alto, or high relief; the finish of each is
differently placed. "In the highest relief, however decided the
shadows may, and must of necessity be, on the plane to which the
figure is attached, the light on the figure itself is kept as unbroken
as possible; and this can only be effected by a selection of open
attitudes; that is, such an arrangement of the limbs as shall not cast
shadows on the figure itself. In basso-relievo, the same general
effect of the figure is given, but by very different means: the
attitude is not selected to avoid shadows on the figure, because,
while the extreme outline is strongly marked, the shadows within it
may be in a great measure suppressed; so that the choice of attitudes
is greater. Mezzo-relievo differs from both; it has neither the
limited attitudes of the first, nor the distinct outline and
suppressed internal markings of the second: on the contrary, the
outline is often less distinct than the forms within it, and hence it
requires, and is fitted for, near inspection. Its imitation may thus
be more absolute, and its execution more finished, than those of the
other styles."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account