Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 68, No. 421, November 1850Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 68, No. 421, November 1850
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
"When we find a man lurking for many days together in a particular
locality, having about him loaded weapons--watching a particular
individual who frequents that locality--a man who does not face
the individual and shoot him, but who coolly waits until he has an
opportunity of discharging the weapon unobserved by his victim or
others--the circumstances appear to show such a perfect adaptation
of means to ends, and such a power of controlling his actions, that
one is quite at a loss to understand why a plea of irresponsibility
should be admitted, except upon the fallacious ground that no
motive could be discovered for the act--a ground, however, which
was not allowed to prevail in the case of Courvoisier, Francis, and
the perpetrators of other atrocious crimes. Observe the lively
sense of his danger, and of his rights and interests, as an accused
person, exhibited by M'Naughten almost immediately after committing
the act--when, fearful lest an inadvertent admission should be
given in evidence against him, he said to the officer[35]--'_But
you won't use this against me?_' Note the matter-of-fact astuteness
with which he attended to his pecuniary interests in May and July;
the total absence of any evidence of the existence of his delusions
during his last sojourn in London; the presence of such proof of
careful, deliberate, and too successful perpetration, as to time,
opportunity, and means; his expression in November towards Sir
Robert Peel--'D----n him!' But, above all, is to be noted the time
when he first gives utterance to anything directly and cogently
favouring the notion on which his life depended--his insane
delusion with regard to Sir Robert Peel--viz., after he had been
for some time incarcerated in Newgate, and when he knew that he
was being examined by a physician, in order to ascertain what had
been his state of mind at the time in question! Dr Munro has there
recorded it.[36] He said--'Mr Salmond, the Procurator-Fiscal, Mr
Sheriff Bell, Mr Sheriff Alison, and _Sir Robert Peel_, might have
put a stop to this system of persecution if they would!' ... 'We
_were afraid of going out after dark for fear of assassination_:
that individuals were made to appear before him like them he had
seen in Glasgow.' ... 'That _he imagined the person at whom he
fired at Charing Cross_ to be one of the crew--a part of the system
that was destroying his health. He observed, that, _when he saw
the person at Charing Cross at whom he fired_, every feeling of
suffering which he had endured for months and years rose up at once
in his mind, and that he conceived that he should obtain peace by
killing him.'"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account