Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 69, No. 424, February 1851Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume 69, No. 424, February 1851
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
with some due allowance of course for the frailties of human nature,
might have been accepted. But when he tells us that, _because_ he was
a guest at the table of the late Lord Holland, and admitted, as he
insinuates, to his intimacy, his prepossessions are disadvantageous to
the author, he is either writing egregious nonsense, or conveying the
reverse of a compliment.
"Had the work," says he, "been anonymous, or had it proceeded--like
many of those innumerable books miscalled histories--from the
Palais Royal or the quays of Paris, we are inclined to think that
a more favourable judgment might have been formed of it, than when
every sentence, nay, almost every line, is weighed against the high
reputation of the author, and the anticipations of readers _like
ourselves_."
The majority of the reading public, however, are by no means in
the exalted position of the critic, who, by the way, was under no
obligation whatever to review the book, if, on perusal, he found
its contents fall greatly short of his expectations. What he means
by talking about publications issuing "from the Palais Royal or the
quays of Paris" we cannot exactly divine, unless he wishes us to
understand that the _Foreign Reminiscences_ intrinsically belong to
the same class of writings--an opinion in which we thoroughly agree.
Such twaddle as this is altogether superfluous. The public generally
has no prepossession either the one way or the other. The name of Lord
Holland is known to them as that of a man who moved in a distinguished
sphere of society, and who must, in his own day, have seen much which
was worth narrating. They have no means of weighing his conversation
against his writings; they accept the latter when laid before them, and
will judge of them strictly according to their actual value.
It appears that the present volume constitutes but a small part of
Lord Holland's written Memoirs. The reason why it is given to us at
the present time is set forth in the Preface, which, being short, we
transcribe entire.
"The recent events on the Continent have induced the editor to
publish the following pages on foreign politics. The time of which
this volume treats has already acquired the interest of a long
past age; and the public will read with pleasure, and perhaps with
profit, the observations on passing events of a contemporary who,
if not wholly impartial, is acknowledged by all who knew him to
have been as candid as he was benevolent.
"The editor has scrupulously abstained from making the slightest
verbal alteration in the text or notes. The omission of four
insignificant sentences is all that he has deemed necessary for
the immediate publication of what was probably written with the
intention of not seeing the light so soon."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account