“A variety, however, may be very interesting; it may even be,
in certain respects, more interesting than the principal type,
acquiring in time and space qualities that raise it above the
type. Brazilian literature, or at least poetry, was already
in the XVIIth century superior to Portuguese. It is by no
means patriotic presumption, which I lack completely, to judge
that, with the development of Brazil, its probable politic and
economic greatness in the future will give to the literary
expression of its life supremacy over Portugal, whose historic
rôle seems over and which, from all appearances, will disappear
in an Iberic union. If this country of ours does not come
apart and split up into several others, each a ‘patria’ with a
dialect of its own, we shall prove true to the prophecies of
Camões and Fr. Luiz de Souza, becoming the legitimate heirs
of Portugal’s language and literature. If such a thing should
happen, it would give us an enormous moral superiority to the
United States and the Spanish-American nations, making of us
the only nation in America with a truly national language and
literature.
“But this literature of ours, which, as a branch of the
Portuguese already has existed for four centuries, possesses
neither perfect continuity, cohesion, nor the unity of the
great literatures,--of the Portuguese, for example. The
principal reason, to explain the phenomenon in a single word,
is that it depended ever, in its earliest periods, rather upon
Portugal and later upon Europe, France especially, than upon
Brazil itself. It always lacked the principle of solidarity,
which would seem to reveal lack of national sentiment. It
always has lacked communicability,--that is, its writers,
who were separated by vast distances and extreme difficulty
of communication, remained strangers one to the other. And I
refer not to personal communication, which is of secondary
importance, but to intellectual communication that is
established through books. The various influences that can be
noted in all our important literary movements are all external.
What is called improperly the Mineira School of the XVIIIth
century, and the Maranhão pléiade of the middle of this (the
XIXth) received their inspiration from Portugal, but did not
transmit it. As is said in military tactics, contact was never
established between the writers or between their intellects.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account