British Quarterly Review, American Edition, Vol. LIV: July and October, 1871Various
History
British Quarterly Review, American Edition, Vol. LIV: July and October, 1871
Various
English periodicals
Again, in p. 160, B., Socrates says to Theodorus:--
'You have capitally expressed my weakness by your simile
(τὴν νόσον μου ἀπείκασας). I, however, am stouter
(ἰσχυρικώτερος) than they; for before now many and many a
Hercules and Theseus' (meaning, of course, many Sophists),
'on meeting me, men brave at talk, have pounded me right
well; but I don't give it up for all that, so strong a
passion has taken possession of my soul for this kind of
exercise. Therefore, do not refuse on your part to prepare
for a contest with me, and so to benefit yourself and me
alike.'
We see no reason whatever why the above should have been diluted down
to such a version as this:--
'I see, Theodorus, that you perfectly apprehend the nature
of my complaint; but I am even more pugnacious than the
giants of old, for I have met with no end of heroes. Many a
Hercules, many a Theseus, mighty in words, have broken my
head; nevertheless, I am always at this rough game, which
inspires me like a passion. Please, then, to indulge me
with a trial, for your own edification as well as mine.'
The following (p. 175, A.) is not satisfactory:--
'And when some one boasts of a catalogue of twenty-five
ancestors, and goes back to Heracles, the son of
Amphitryon, he cannot understand his poverty of ideas. Why
is he unable to calculate that Amphitryon had a
twenty-fifth ancestor, who might have been anybody, and was
such as fortune made him, and he had a fiftieth, and so on?
He is amused at the notion that he cannot do a sum, and
thinks that a little arithmetic would have got rid of his
senseless vanity.'
What Plato really says is this:--
'But, when men pride themselves on a list of
five-and-twenty ancestors, and trace them back to Heracles,
the son of Amphitryon, it seems to him surprising that they
should make these trumpery reckonings; and they should not
be able (further) to calculate that the twenty-fifth from
Amphitryon backwards was just such a person as fortune
chanced to make him, or at least the fiftieth from him, and
thus to get rid of the vanity of a senseless mind,--at this
he cannot suppress a smile.'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account