[Footnote 67: Dr. B--y reads. The mighty Tall-mast Thumb. Mr. D--s, The mighty Thumbing Thumb. Mr. T--d reads, Thundering. I think Thomas more agreeable to the great simplicity so apparent in our author.] [Footnote 68: That learned historian Mr. S--n, in the third number of his criticism on our author, takes great pains to explode this passage. "It is," says he, "difficult to guess what giants are here meant, unless the giant Despair in the 'Pilgrim's Progress,' or the giant Greatness in the 'Royal Villain;' for I have heard of no other sort of giants in the reign of king Arthur." Petrus Burmannus makes three Tom Thumbs, one whereof he supposes to have been the same person whom the Greeks call Hercules; and that by these giants are to be understood the Centaurs slain by that hero. Another Tom Thumb he contends to have been no other than the Hermes Trismegistus of the ancients. The third Tom Thumb he places under the reign of king Arthur; to which third Tom Thumb, says he, the actions of the other two were attributed. Now, though I know that this opinion is supported by an assertion of Justus Lipsius, "Thomam illum Thumbum non alium quam Herculem fuisse satis constat," yet shall I venture to oppose one line of Mr. Midwinter against them all: "In Arthur's court Tom Thumb did live." "But then," says Dr. B--y, "if we place Tom Thumb in the court of king Arthur, it will be proper to place that court out of Britain, where no giants were ever heard of." Spenser, in his "Fairy Queen," is of another opinion, where, describing Albion, he says:-- "Far within a savage nation dwelt Of hideous gants." And in the same canto:-- "Then Elfar, with two brethren giants had The one of which had two heads-- The other three." Risum teneatis, amici.] [Footnote 69: "To whisper in books," says Mr. D--s, "is arrant nonsense." I am afraid this learned man does not sufficiently understand the extensive meaning of the word whisper. If he had rightly understood what is meant by the "senses whisp'ring the soul," in the Persian Princess, or what "whisp'ring like winds" is in Aurengzebe, or like thunder in another author, he would have understood this. Emmeline in Dryden sees a voice, but she was born blind, which is an excuse Panthea cannot plead in Cyrus, who hears a sight: "Your description will surpass All fiction, painting, or dumb show of horror, That ever ears yet heard, or eyes beheld." When Mr. D--s understands these, he will understand whispering in books.] [Footnote 70: "Some ruffian stept into his father's place, And more than half begot him."--"Mary Queen of Scots." ] [Footnote 71: "For Ulamar seems sent express from Heaven, To civilize this rugged Indian clime."--"Lib. Asserted." ]