Hebrew literature -- History and criticism; Jewish literature -- History and criticism; Jews in literature
One of the first writers to combat, on the continent of Europe,
Voltaire’s depreciation of Shakespeare was Lessing. But his eulogy
was dated 1759. A year earlier (1758) Moses Mendelssohn, in his essay
on the Sublime, had anticipated Lessing’s judgment. But his influence
did not lead the new-Hebrew school to translate Shakespeare. It was
not till near the middle of the nineteenth century that we find
Hebrew translations even of such famous soliloquies as Hamlet’s “To
be or not to be.” In 1842 Fabius Mieses and in 1856 N. P. Krassensohn
rendered the passage. Both, however, were dependent on Mendelssohn,
translating his German rendering. Others, at the same period, turned
a few passages, including one of Richard II’s monologues, from German
versions into Hebrew.
“To-day we exact our revenge from the English! They took our Bible and
made it their own. We, in return, have captured their Shakespeare.
Is it not a sweet revenge?” With these words Smolenskin opened his
introduction to Salkinson’s Hebrew translation of _Othello_.
It is not easy to explain how it happened that we had to wait till
1874 for the first Hebrew adaptation of a Shakespearean drama. In
fact, with the exception of Salkinson’s _Romeo and Juliet_ (1878), S.
L. Gordon’s _King Lear_ (1899), and Isaac Barb’s _Macbeth_ (1883), I
know of no Hebrew version of plays by the author of _Hamlet_, which
latter drama so far as I have observed, has not even been printed in
Yiddish. (Dr. Halper, however, informs me that _Hamlet_ was translated
into Hebrew by H. J. Bornstein, and that his version appeared in the
pages of Ha-Zefirah somewhere about 1900). _Julius Cæsar_ appeared
in Yiddish in 1886. _King Lear_ has also been printed in the same
language, and the _Merchant of Venice_ received the same honor, at the
hand of Basil Dahl, in New York, in 1899. I use the words “_printed_
in Yiddish” advisedly, because there are extant in manuscript acting
versions of other plays used by Yiddish companies. Of course, select
passages from Shakespeare have often been rendered into Hebrew, as, for
instance, in that curious publication _Young’s Israelitish Gleaner and
Biblical Repository_, Edinburgh, 1855 (pp. 24, 16). The lack of Hebrew
translations may be explained by two considerations. The _Merchant
of Venice_, despite its sympathetic treatment of some aspects of
Shylock’s character, dealt so deadly a blow at the Jews, that there
could be no enthusiasm with regard to the other works. But more
operative was another fact. The available Hebraists for the most part
were ignorant of English. The _Macbeth_ mentioned above was translated
not from the original, but from Schiller’s German.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account