Cave Hunting: Researches on the evidence of caves respecting the early inhabitants of EuropeDawkins, William Boyd
History
Cave Hunting: Researches on the evidence of caves respecting the early inhabitants of Europe
Dawkins, William Boyd
Antiquities, Prehistoric -- Europe; Caves -- Europe; Europe -- Antiquities; Prehistoric peoples -- Europe
With respect to the ethnological value of the platycnemic _tibia_,
I conceive we are as yet very much in the dark. That it is a
race-character would seem to me in the highest degree improbable,
seeing that it would be difficult to find any other points of
resemblance between the Cro-magnon platycnemic men and those
whose remains were met with in the Gibraltar caves, although the
platycnemism is of the same kind in each; and still less could
the former gigantic race be identified with the occupants of
the Perthi-Chwareu sepulchre, from whom they differ not only in
stature, but even more remarkably in cranial conformation.
If, then, platycnemism cannot be regarded as of any value as a
race-character, it can _a fortiori_ be still less looked upon as
indicative of simian tendencies, a notion that M. Broca seems
somewhat inclined to favour. It is quite true that the _tibiæ_
of the gorilla and of the chimpanzee are, to a certain extent,
platycnemic; but it is by no means so much so as the human
platycnemic bone. The _tibia_ of a male gorilla in the College of
Surgeons has a latitudinal index of ·681, and that of a female of
·650, whilst that of the chimpanzee is ·611, or exactly the mean of
the Perthi-Chwareu bones. It is needless to insist upon the other
marked distinctions between the simian and the human _tibia_; but
as regards platycnemism it will be obvious, if we are disposed to
trace it to any genetic descent, that the descendant has, in this
respect, at one time far out-simianized the Simiæ.
But this comparison with the anthropoid apes may, perhaps, afford
ground for a suggestion respecting some possible connection
between this peculiar form of the _tibia_ and the habits of the
people amongst whom it has been observed. One great distinction
between the human and the simian foot consists in their respective
adaptations to totally distinct functions. In the one case it
is simply an organ of support and progression; in the other,
for the most part, of prehension. This necessarily involves a
considerable difference in the proportions, &c., of the muscles by
which the greater mobility and adaptability of the foot, and more
particularly of the digits, are ensured. Would it not, then, be
admissible to inquire how far, at any rate, posterior platycnemism
may be connected with the greater freedom of motion and general
adaptability of the toes enjoyed by those peoples whose feet have
not been subjected to the confinement of shoes or other coverings,
and who at the same time have been compelled to lead an active
existence in a rude and rugged or mountainous and wooded country,
where the exigencies of the chase would demand the utmost agility
in climbing and otherwise?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account