Charles Bradlaugh: a Record of His Life and Work, Volume 1 (of 2): With an Account of his Parliamentary Struggle, Politics and Teachings. Seventh EditionRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
History
Charles Bradlaugh: a Record of His Life and Work, Volume 1 (of 2): With an Account of his Parliamentary Struggle, Politics and Teachings. Seventh Edition
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Bradlaugh, Charles, 1833-1891
The italics are mine; and if Mr Collier meant to imply that he received
this information from his client or his attorney--the only persons
from whom he should have received information bearing on the conduct
of this case--he still further dishonoured himself, because the
utmost candour was shown him in laying the facts before him, and most
assuredly no such statement as that quoted could have been made to him
by sane men who knew the facts.
But to return to Mr Collier's speech. I will give just two more
quotations, and then leave it:--
"I should be extremely sorry," he said, "if I were understood, as
the advocate of Mr Bradlaugh or anybody else, as for one moment
defending any circulation, either by printing or by word of mouth, of
anything libellous, seditious, or blasphemous.... If Mr Bradlaugh had
been permitted to preach, and if he had preached anything improper,
blasphemous, or seditious, I should not have complained of the
superintendent; on the contrary, I should praise him if he had taken
the proper measures for bringing him before a court of justice."
"I will conclude," he further said, "with this remark, that I cannot
help thinking that if the doctrines of this Secular Society, or any
other Society, are preached, which you and I and all of us may think
pernicious, by far the best thing is to let them alone. 'Truth is
great and will prevail,' and we need not fear that the foundation of
our religion will be shaken by a thousand Bradlaughs; and I cannot
think of anything so pernicious and likely to prevent that very object
we seek to accomplish, and to elevate persons such as these from
obscurity into fame, as by making them unjustly martyrs. I cannot
help thinking that the superintendent of the police, although acting
from the very best motives, was acting with very great haste and
indiscretion."
If Mr Collier had been briefed by the other side also, he could hardly
have made a more equivocal speech; and it will be easily understood
how much it was likely to prejudice both the judge and jury against a
man whose opinions were so well known, and who had made no pretence of
concealing them. The defence made every effort to avail themselves of
the _odium theologicum_ when it came to Mr Bradlaugh's turn to take
his place in the witness-box. Mr Montagu Smith, Q.C., counsel for the
defence, wished to cross-examine Mr Bradlaugh on some former lectures
in which he expressed his disbelief in the Bible; Mr Collier objected;
Mr Smith persisted; Baron Channell then allowed the question, taking
note of Mr Collier's objection; Mr Smith again put his question, and my
father replied: "I object to answer that question on the ground that
if I answer it in the affirmative it will subject me to a criminal
prosecution." Then came a little scene, which will strike those
who have been in the law courts with Mr Bradlaugh as by no means
unfamiliar:--
"His Lordship then asked for the Act of Parliament, and
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account