Charles Darwin and the Theory of Natural SelectionPoulton, Edward Bagnall, Sir
Science
Charles Darwin and the Theory of Natural Selection
Poulton, Edward Bagnall, Sir
Darwin, Charles, 1809-1882; Natural selection
“You must know that I look at it, as very important, for the
reception of the view of species not being immutable, the fact of
the greatest Geologist and Botanist in England taking _any sort
of interest_ in the subject: I am sure it will do much to break
down prejudices.”
In the following January Darwin received a letter from Wallace, and
his reply (on the 25th) shows how much relieved and pleased he was
at its generous spirit. Alluding to Lyell’s and Hooker’s action in
his “Autobiography” Darwin says:--“I was at first very unwilling
to consent, as I thought Mr. Wallace might consider my doing so
unjustifiable, for I did not then know how generous and noble was his
disposition.” It was this letter which conveyed the knowledge to him
and set his mind at rest on the subject.
Thus ended one of the most interesting and memorable episodes in the
history of science. It was sufficiently remarkable that two naturalists
in widely-separated lands should have independently arrived at the
theory which was to be the turning-point in the history of biology
and of many other sciences--although such simultaneous discoveries
have been known before; it was still more remarkable that one of the
two should unknowingly have chosen the other to advise him upon the
theory which was to be for ever associated with both their names.
It was a magnificent answer to those who believed that the progress
of scientific discovery implies continual jealousy and bitterness,
that the conditions attending the first publication of the theory of
natural selection were the beginning of a life-long friendship and of
mutual confidence and esteem.[F]
[Sidenote: FRIENDSHIP WITH WALLACE.]
It is justifiable to speak of this episode as the _beginning_ of
Darwin’s and Wallace’s friendship, for the latter writes (February,
1895):--
“I had met him _once_ only for a few minutes at the Brit. Mus.
before I went to the East.”
Later on Darwin, in his letters to Wallace, more than once alluded to
the simultaneous publication of their essays. Thus he wrote, April
18th, 1869, congratulating Wallace on his article in the _Quarterly
Review_ for that month:--
“I was also much pleased at your discussing the difference
between our views and Lamarck’s. One sometimes sees the odious
expression, ‘Justice to myself compels me to say,’ &c., but you
are the only man I ever heard of who persistently does himself an
injustice, and never demands justice. Indeed, you ought in the
review to have alluded to your paper in the ‘Linnean Journal,’
and I feel sure all our friends will agree in this. But you
cannot ‘Burke’ yourself however much you may try, as may be seen
in half the articles which appear.”
And again, on April 20th of the following year, he wrote:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account