Charles Dickens: A critical studyChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
General
Charles Dickens: A critical study
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870
A good example of my meaning can be found, for instance, in such a
character as Quilp. Dickens may, for all I know, have had originally
some idea of describing Quilp as the bitter and unhappy cripple, a
deformity whose mind is stunted along with his body. But if he had
such an idea, he soon abandoned it. Quilp is not in the least unhappy.
His whole picturesqueness consists in the fact that he has a kind of
hellish happiness, an atrocious hilarity that makes him go bounding
about like an indiarubber ball. Quilp is not in the least bitter; he
has an unaffected gaiety, an expansiveness, an universality. He desires
to hurt people in the same hearty way that a good-natured man desires
to help them. He likes to poison people with the same kind of clamorous
camaraderie with which an honest man likes to stand them drink. Quilp
is not in the least stunted in mind; he is not in reality even stunted
in body--his body, that is, does not in any way fall short of what he
wants it to do. His smallness gives him rather the promptitude of a
bird or the precipitance of a bullet. In a word, Quilp is precisely the
devil of the Middle Ages; he belongs to that amazingly healthy period
when even the lost spirits were hilarious.
This heartiness and vivacity in the villains of Dickens is worthy of
note because it is directly connected with his own cheerfulness. This
is a truth little understood in our time, but it is a very essential
one. If optimism means a general approval, it is certainly true that
the more a man becomes an optimist the more he becomes a melancholy
man. If he manages to praise everything, his praise will develop an
alarming resemblance to a polite boredom. He will say that the marsh
is as good as the garden; he will mean that the garden is as dull as
the marsh. He may force himself to say that emptiness is good, but he
will hardly prevent himself from asking what is the good of such good.
This optimism does exist--this optimism which is more hopeless than
pessimism--this optimism which is the very heart of hell. Against such
an aching vacuum of joyless approval there is only one antidote--a
sudden and pugnacious belief in positive evil. This world can be made
beautiful again by beholding it as a battlefield. When we have defined
and isolated the evil thing, the colours come back into everything
else. When evil things have become evil, good things, in a blazing
apocalypse, become good. There are some men who are dreary because they
do not believe in God; but there are many others who are dreary because
they do not believe in the devil. The grass grows green again when we
believe in the devil, the roses grow red again when we believe in the
devil.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account