One or two of his published letters about this period have a special
interest, for they show that his views on the origin of species were
undergoing a gradual modification. Speaking of some strange variations
in the flower of an orchideous plant,[122] he refers, half in jest, to
"ugly facts, as Hooker, clinging (like me) to the orthodox faith, calls
these and other abnormal vagaries"; and again, the following sentences
do not come from a man who is firm in his belief[123]:--
"When Huxley, Hooker, and Wollaston were at Darwin's last
week, they (all four of them) ran a tilt against species
further, I believe, than they are deliberately prepared to
go--Wollaston least unorthodox. I cannot easily see how they
can go so far, and not embrace the whole Lamarckian
doctrine. Huxley held forth last week about the oxlip, which
he says is unknown on the Continent. If we had met with it
in Madeira and nowhere else, or the cowslip, should we not
have voted them true species? Darwin finds, among his
fifteen varieties of the common pigeon, three good genera
and about fifteen good species, according to the received
mode of species and genus-making of the best ornithologists,
and the bony skeleton varying with the rest! After all, did
we not come from an ourang, seeing that man is of the Old
World, and not from the American type of anthropomorphous
mammalia?"
Sir Charles and Lady Lyell were again on the Continent in the summer of
1856, examining the drifts of Northern Germany, visiting Humboldt at
Berlin, discussing geological questions, especially in regard to
Carboniferous plants, at Breslau with Roemer and Goeppert; working over
the Riesengebirge; then going on to Dresden, and passing through the
Saxon Switzerland to Aussig. The coalfield north-west of the former city
was not neglected, the great breccia beds of the Rothliegende were again
examined, and account was taken of Ramsay's opinion that certain British
Permian breccias were glacial in origin. Close attention was also
bestowed upon the great masses of hard quartzose grit, through which the
Elbe has carved its way--the Quader of Saxony; for this formation, "a
grit wholly deficient in calcareous matter, corresponds to the more
purely calcareous rock (Chalk) of Great Britain, and yet contains here
and there the same shells." He did not neglect the Brown Coal[124]
between Töplitz and Aussig, and, on reaching Prague, made the
acquaintance of Barrande, who took him to see those older Palæozoic
rocks among which the great palæontologist had been labouring for nearly
a quarter of a century. Then the travellers proceeded to Vienna, and
after that to the Styrian Alps, to visit various interesting sections in
the Salzkammergut, such as the classic ground at Gosau and the Triassic
limestones near Hallstadt, where the last survivors of the Palæozoic
ages are entombed with the representatives of the period.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account