Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 04 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 04 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
There are considerations belonging to the present period which give
new strength to this proposition. Public Opinion, which, under a
popular government, makes and unmakes laws, and which for a time was
passive and acquiescent, now lifts itself everywhere in the States
where the Act is sought to be enforced, and demands a change. Already
three States, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Michigan, by formal
resolutions presented to the Senate, have concurred in this demand.
Tribunals of law are joining at last with the people. The Superior
Court of Cincinnati has denied the power of Congress over this
subject. And now, almost while I speak, comes the solemn judgment of
the Supreme Court of Wisconsin, delivered after elaborate argument,
on successive occasions, before a single judge, and then before the
whole bench, declaring this Act a violation of the Constitution. In
response to public opinion, broad and general, if not universal, at
the North, swelling alike from village and city, from seaboard and
lake,--judicially attested, legislatively declared, and represented
also by numerous petitions from good men without distinction of
party,--in response to this Public Opinion, as well as in obedience
to my own fixed convictions, I deem it my duty not to lose this
opportunity of pressing the repeal of the Fugitive Slave Act once more
upon the Senate. I move, Sir, to strike out all after the enacting
clause in the pending bill, and insert instead these words:--
"That the Act of Congress, approved September 18, 1850, usually
known as the 'Fugitive Slave Act,' be, and the same is hereby,
repealed."
And on this motion I ask the yeas and nays.
On taking his seat, Mr. Sumner was followed by Mr. Butler, of South
Carolina, when the following passage occurred.
MR. BUTLER. Mr. President, I have no idea of irritating sectional
differences. If gentlemen have the opinions which it seems the
gentleman from Massachusetts entertains, be it so. I assure him
I do not intend to bandy words with him. He talks as if he was
disposed to maintain the Constitution of the United States; but if
I were to put to him a question now, I would ask him one which he,
perhaps, would not answer me honestly.
MR. SUMNER. I will answer any question.
MR. BUTLER. Then I ask you honestly now, whether, all laws of
Congress being put out of the question, you would recommend to
Massachusetts to pass a law to deliver up fugitives from slavery?
MR. SUMNER. The Senator asks me a question, and I answer, frankly,
that no temptation, no inducement, would draw me in any way to
sanction the return of any man to slavery. Others will speak for
themselves. In this respect I speak for myself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account