Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 07 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 07 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
“We must limit the war to the purposes so distinctly
avowed by the Administration, or the sun of our national
prosperity will set in darkness and gloom, to rise again,
if at all, only after years of bloodshed and anarchy.
Proclaim the policy of Emancipation, and all hope of a
reconstruction of the Union will be crushed out. All the
loyal elements in Maryland, Kentucky, and Missouri will
be alienated at once, and every prospect of awakening the
dormant loyalty in the seceded States will have passed
away. It will come to this, that we must subjugate or be
subjugated. The people of the South would defend their
homes and their firesides to the last extremity, as we
would do, should the chances of war favor them. The present
generation would not see the end of such a contest, unless
the North should be conquered and subdued by the aid of
foreign bayonets or internal dissensions. From such a war
we may well pray to be delivered.”
The _Norfolk County Journal_ declared dissent.
“We are not prepared to indorse the doctrines to which
Mr. Sumner gave utterance in his Worcester speech. They
strike us as not pertinent to the present stage of the
Rebellion. Though their application may become a necessity
in the future, public sentiment is as yet unready to adopt
and enforce them. They were especially infelicitous in
being advanced at a Convention to which men of varying
views of public policy had been invited, and their
influence has not conduced to that harmony of political
action in Massachusetts which it is desirable to bring
about.”
The _Springfield Republican_, among many things, said:--
“We fear it is but an illustration of the mental perversity
produced by entire absorption in a single aspect of a great
question, without regard to its manifold relations, and by
the ‘sacred animosity,’ which, too exclusively nourished,
renders the best men reckless of means in the pursuit of
what they consider the chief end of life.”
On the contrary, the able Boston correspondent of that paper
wrote:--
“Charles Sumner’s speech was the great event of the day,
however. It was an epoch and a victory in itself. The
right thing was said, in the right way, at the right time,
by the right man. It was wise, conservative, practical,
as Mr. Sumner always is, and it unquestionably met the
views of four fifths of the audience. Those who did
not enthusiastically applaud said, ‘Oh, it isn’t quite
time; Sumner is right; this will be the _result_, we
hope and expect; but let us wait for Providence and the
Administration.’”
The _Boston Post_, representing the Democracy, declared itself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account