Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 10 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 10 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
“Is it not obvious enough, that men cannot get together and
count themselves, and say they are so many hundreds and so
many thousands, and judge of their own qualifications, and
call themselves the people, and set up a government? _Why,
another set of men, forty miles off, on the same day, with the
same propriety, with as good qualifications, and in as large
numbers, may meet and set up another government._”
“When, in the course of events, it becomes necessary to
ascertain the will of the people on a new exigency or a new
state of things or of opinion, _the legislative power provides
for that ascertainment by an ordinary act of legislation_.”
“What do I contend for? I say that the will of the people must
prevail, when it is ascertained; but there must be _some legal
and authentic mode of ascertaining that will_, and then the
people may make what government they please.”
“All that is necessary here is, that the will of the people
should be ascertained by some regular rule of proceeding,
_prescribed by previous law_.”
“But the law and the Constitution, the whole system of American
institutions, do not contemplate a case in which a resort will
be necessary to proceedings _aliunde_, or _outside of the law
and the Constitution_, for the purpose of amending the frame of
government.”[205]
Happily, we are not constrained to any such revolutionary proceeding.
The new governments can all be organized by Congress, which is the
natural guardian of the people, without any immediate government, and
within the jurisdiction of the National Constitution. Indeed, with
the State governments already _vacated_ by Rebellion, the Constitution
becomes, for the time, the supreme and only law, binding alike on
President and Congress, so that neither can establish any law or
institution incompatible with it; and the whole Rebel region, deprived
of all local government, lapses under the exclusive jurisdiction of
Congress, precisely as any other territory,--or, in other words, the
negation of the local government leaves the whole vast region without
any other government than Congress, unless the President should
undertake to govern it by military power. Startling as this proposition
may seem, especially to all who believe that there is a “divinity doth
hedge” a State hardly less than a king, it will appear, on careful
consideration, to be as well founded in the Constitution as it is
simple and natural, while it affords easy and constitutional solution
to all present embarrassments.
I have no theory to maintain, but only the truth; and in presenting
this argument for Congressional government I simply follow teachings
which I cannot control. The wisdom of Socrates, in the words of Plato,
has aptly described these teachings, when he says,--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account