Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 10 (of 20)Sumner, Charles
History
Charles Sumner: his complete works, volume 10 (of 20)
Sumner, Charles
Slavery -- United States; Speeches, addresses, etc., American
The debate was continued until the Senator from Illinois [Mr.
TRUMBULL] proposed that the Chair should proceed to administer
the oath, while Mr. Sumner expressed a hope that the Chair
would consent to administer the oath to him.
Shortly afterwards the President _pro tempore_ said:--
“The Chair proposes now to take and subscribe this oath, in
pursuance of the law of 2d July last, and, that being done,
the Chair will administer the oath _to such members as will
voluntarily take it_.”
The oath was then administered to Mr. Foot by Mr. Foster.
Resuming the chair, the President _pro tempore_ then said:--
“The Chair will now direct the Clerk to call, in
alphabetical order, the names of all Senators who have been
elected or reëlected since the 2d July, 1862, that being
the day of the approval of the Act; and _such Senators
present_, whose names shall be called, _as choose to do
so_, will come forward to the Secretary’s desk and receive
the oath of office administered by the Chair, _after which
they will have an opportunity to subscribe the oath_.”
The Senators present, whose names were called, some of them
after delay, came forward and took the oath; and then, at the
suggestion of the Chair, Mr. Sumner withdrew the resolution.
The Senator from Delaware [Mr. BAYARD] was not then present.
Before withdrawing the resolution, Mr. Sumner, in reply to Mr.
Reverdy Johnson, of Maryland, again vindicated the proposed
rule, insisting that the statute was applicable to Senators as
“civil officers,” concluding as follows.
It is our duty to guard the loyalty of this Chamber. In requiring that
a person shall purge himself with regard to the past, we simply take
a new assurance of fidelity for the present. Others may think that
Jefferson Davis, Robert Toombs, or Judah Benjamin may resume his seat
in this body, on taking a simple oath to support the Constitution. I
do not think so; and I gladly seize the earliest opportunity, since
the commentary of the Senator from Maryland, to declare my conviction
that no person, whose loyalty is not manifest to the Senate, can be
allowed to approach your desk and take the oath of a Senator. The
Senate must shut the door upon him. This is not the first time that I
have made this declaration: nor have I contented myself with making
the declaration; I have argued it. Nothing is clearer than this: a
traitor cannot be a member of the Senate. But a person who cannot take
this oath, retroactive though it be, must have been a traitor. Once a
traitor, always a traitor, unless where changed by pardon or amnesty.
I know not what changes may be required by changing events. For myself,
I shall always welcome every act of just clemency or condonation. But
for the present the statute is wise and conservative. It only remains
that we should stand by it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account