"'The Idea of March' is a capital book. The plot does not depend for
its interest upon anything more fantastic than an old gentleman's
belief that a family curse will take effect unless his son marries
by a given date. The complications which arise from this son's being
really in love with a girl whom he believes to have treated his
friend, Captain Disney, vary badly, and getting engaged to another
girl, who transfers her affections to the same Captain Disney, are
skilfully worked out, while the dialogue is, in parts, extremely
bright, and the description of the founding of the Norchester branch
of the Women's Sanitary League really funny."--_Literary World_.
"'The Idea of March,' in spite of its classical name, is a story of
the present time, and a very good one, full of lively conversation,
which carries us merrily on, and not without a fund of deeper feeling
and higher principal."--_Guardian_.
PART OF THE PROPERTY.
By Beatrice Whitby.
"The book is a thoroughly good one. The theme is fairly familiar--the
rebellion of a spirited girl against a match which has been arranged
for her without her knowledge or consent; her resentment at being
treated, not as a woman with, a heart and will, but as 'part of the
property'; and her final discovery, which is led up to with real
dramatic skill, that the thing against which her whole nature had
risen in revolt has become the one desire of her heart. The mutual
relations each to each of the impetuous Hedge, her self-willed,
stubborn grandfather, who has arranged the match, and her lover
Jocelyn, with his loyal, devoted, sweetly-balanced nature, are
portrayed with fine truth of insight; but perhaps the author's
greatest triumph is the portrait of Mrs. Lindsay, who, with the
knowledge of the terrible skeleton in the cupboard of her apparently
happy home, wears so bravely the mask of light gaiety as to deceive
everybody but the one man who knows her secret. It is refreshing to
read a novel in which there is not a trace of slipshod work."
CASPAR BROOKE'S DAUGHTER.
By Adeline Sergeant.
"'Caspar Brooke's Daughter' is as good as other stories from the same
hand--perhaps better, it is not of the sort that has much really
marked originality or force of style, yet there is a good deal of
clever treatment in it It was quite on the cards that Caspar himself
might prove a bore or a prig or something else equally annoying.
His daughter, too--the fair and innocent convent-bred girl--would
in some hands have been really tedious. The difficulties of the
leading situation--a daughter obliged to pass from one parent to
another on account of their 'incompatibility'--are cleverly conveyed.
The wife's as well as the husband's part is treated with feeling
and reticence--qualities which towards the end disappear to a
certain extent. It is a story in some ways--not in all--above the
average."--_Athenæum_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account