Constitutional history -- United States; United States -- Politics and government; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
“The authority of Constitutions over governments, and the sovereignty
of the people over Constitutions, are truths which are at all times
necessary to be kept in mind; _and at no time, perhaps, more necessary
than at present_.” This impressive statement of the truth that
the “governments,” state “legislatures,” never were placed by the
Fifth Article above the Constitution in which it is, and above the
sovereignty of the people, mentioned therein as “conventions,” and
cannot be placed there by another government, the Congress, is not a
statement made in the heat of the controversy about the Eighteenth
Amendment. It is the statement of James Madison, author of the Fifth
Article, made in the Virginia House of Delegates in 1799;
It is becoming almost impossible for us, as we sit in these conventions
and hear every word that is said, to understand the source of the
modern thought, if we can dignify it by calling it “thought,” that
the Fifth Article is a power of attorney from the citizens of America
to the state governments, every member of which is elected by the
citizens of the respective states and not by the citizens of America.
It is beginning to grow upon us that any such “thought” is based on
sheer assumption and that the entire record of the “conventions” is a
closed book to those who hold the assumption. We know that they have
the explicit statement of the Tenth Amendment, that the Constitution
gives no power of any kind to any donee except the one new American
government, the government with the enumerated powers of the First
Article. As no power of attorney was ever written or can be conceived
except one which grants the attorney in fact some power, the Tenth
Amendment makes absolutely certain that neither the Fifth Article nor
the entire Constitution gives to the state legislatures any power as
attorneys in fact for the citizens of America.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account