Constitutional history -- United States; United States -- Politics and government; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
Independence, citizens of a nation--_not Virginia_--who must obey the
laws of a legislature only some of whose members Virginians would elect.
“Suppose,” he says, “the people of Virginia should wish to alter” this
new government which governs them. “Can a majority of them do it?
No; because they are connected with other men, or, in other words,
consolidated with other states. When the people of Virginia, at a
future day, shall wish to alter their government, though they should
be unanimous in this desire, yet they may be prevented therefrom by a
despicable minority at the extremity of the United States. The founders
of your own Constitution made your government changeable: but the power
of changing it is gone from you. Whither is it gone? It is placed in
the same hands that hold the rights of twelve other states; and those
who hold those rights have right and power to keep them. It is not
the particular government of Virginia: one of the leading features of
that government is, that a majority can alter it, when necessary for
the public good. This government is not a Virginian, but an American
government.” (3 _Ell. Deb._ 55.)
How forceful and effective was this objection, we average Americans of
this generation may well realize when we know that the Constitution was
ratified in Virginia by the scant majority of ten votes. In New York
and Massachusetts and other states, the adoption was secured by similar
small majorities. In North Carolina, the first convention refused to
adopt at all.
Furthermore, it is recorded history that, in Massachusetts, in
Virginia, in New York, and elsewhere, the vote of the people would
have been against the adoption of the Constitution, if a promise had
not been made to them by the advocates of the Constitution. It was
the historic promise that Congress, under the _mode of procedure_
prescribed in Article V, would propose new _declaratory_ Articles,
suggested by the various conventions and specifically securing certain
_reserved_ rights and powers of all Americans from all ability of
_government_ to interfere therewith. This historic promise was
fulfilled, when the first Congress of the new nation proposed the
suggested declaratory Articles and ten of them were adopted. These
are the Articles now known as the first ten Amendments. It has been
settled beyond dispute, in the Supreme Court, that every one of the
declarations in these ten Articles was already in the Constitution when
it was originally adopted by the citizens of America.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account