Civics and HealthAllen, William H. (WIlliam Harvey)
Science
Civics and Health
Allen, William H. (WIlliam Harvey)
Hygiene; Public health
Self-laudation continues this hold of the medical profession upon the
lay imagination. One physician may challenge another's faults, ridicule
his remedies, call his antitoxin dangerous poison, but their common
profession he proudly styles "the most exalted form of altruism." Young
men and women beginning the study or the practice of medicine are
exhorted to continue its traditions of self-denial, and in their very
souls to place human welfare before personal or pecuniary advancement.
Newspapers repeat exhortation and laudation. We laymen pass on the
story that we know is not universally true,--physicians know,
physicians apply what they know without consciousness of error,
physicians must be implicitly trusted.
For a physician to give poison when he means to give food is worse, not
better, than for a layman to make the same mistake. Neither the moral
code nor the law of self-preservation enjoins a tuberculous mother to
take alcohol or to sleep in an unventilated room, even if an uninformed
physician prescribes it. Instruction in physiology and hygiene would be
futile if those who are educated as to the elementary facts of hygiene
and physiology must blindly follow blind physicians. A family doctor
who gives cod-liver oil for anaemia due to adenoids may do a child as
much harm as a nurse who drugs the baby to make it sleep. The physician
who refuses to tell the board of health when smallpox or typhoid fever
first breaks out takes human life just as truly as if he tore up the
tracks in front of an express train. This is another way of saying that
parents and teachers must fit themselves to know whether the family
physician and their community's physicians are efficient practitioners
and teachers. Every one can learn enough about the preventable causes
of sickness and depleted vitality to insist upon the ounce of education
and prevention that is better than a pound of cure.
For its sins of omission, as for its sins of commission, the medical
profession shares responsibility with laymen. For years leading
educators, business men, hospital directors, public officials, have
known that communicable diseases could be stamped out. The methods have
been demonstrated. There is absolutely no excuse to-day for epidemics
of typhoid in Trenton, Pittsburg, or Scranton, for epidemics of scarlet
fever in the small towns of Minnesota, for uninterrupted epidemics of
tuberculosis everywhere. Had either laymen, physicians, or
school-teachers made proper use of the knowledge that has been in
text-books for a generation, this country would be saving thousands of
lives and millions of dollars every year. Our _doing_ and _getting
done_ have lagged behind our _knowing_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account