Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
The “real America,” I say, because I mean the America of mind and
attitude, the inner truth, not the outer actuality. That outer
actuality has made the fact of the pioneer almost grotesque. The
frontier is closed; the nation is the most prosperous among the
harassed ones of the earth; there is no need for the old perpetual
preoccupation with material existence. In spite of trade depressions
and wars and their aftermaths, we have conquered that problem. But we
have not conquered ourselves. We must still go on in the old terms,
as if the purpose of making money in order to make more money were as
important as the purpose of raising bread in order to support life.
The facts have changed, but we have not changed, only deflected our
interests. Where the pioneer cleared a wilderness, the modern financier
subdues a forest of competitors. He puts the same amount of energy and
essentially the same quality of thought into his task to-day, although
the practical consequences can hardly be described as identical.
And what have been those practical consequences? As the industrial
revolution expanded, coincidently with the filling up of the country,
the surplus began to grow. That surplus was expended not towards
the enrichment of our life--if one omit the perfunctory bequests for
education--but towards the most obvious of unnecessary luxuries,
the grandiose maintenance of our women. The daughters of pioneer
mothers found themselves without a real job, often, indeed, the
chief instrument for advertising their husbands’ incomes. For years
the Victorian conception of women as ornaments dominated what we
were pleased to call our “better elements”--those years, to put it
brutally, which coincided with that early prosperity that made the
conception possible. If the leisure of the landed gentry class of
colonial times had been other than a direct importation, if there
had ever been a genuine _salon_ in our cultural history, or if our
early moneyed aristocracy had ever felt itself really secure from the
constant challenge of immigrant newcomers, this surplus might have
gone towards the deepening and widening of what we could have felt to
be an indigenous tradition. Or if, indeed, the Cavalier traditions of
the South (the only offshoot of the Renaissance in America) had not
been drained of all vitality by the Civil War and its economic and
intellectual consequences, this surplus might have enhanced the more
gracious aspects of those traditions. None of these possibilities
existed; and when prosperity smiled on us we were embarrassed. We were
parvenus--even to this day the comic series, “Bringing Up Father,” has
a native tang. We know exactly how Mr. Jiggs feels when Mrs. Jiggs
drags him away to a concert and makes him dress for a stiff, formal
dinner, when all his heart desires is to smoke his pipe and play poker
with Dinty and the boys. Indeed, this series, which appears regularly
in all the newspapers controlled by Mr. Hearst, will repay the social
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account