Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
In fact, when we try to survey the currents of our entire national
life, to assess these vagrant winds of doctrine free from the
ingenuousness that our own academic experience or training may give
us, the more shall we perceive that the dichotomy between the cultural
and intellectual life of men and women in this country has been
carried farther than anywhere else in the world. We need only recall
the older women’s clubs of the comic papers--in truth, the actual
women’s clubs of to-day as revealed by small-town newspaper reports of
their meetings--the now deliquescent Browning Clubs, the Chautauquas,
the church festivals, the rural normal schools for teachers, the
women’s magazines, the countless national organizations for improving,
elevating, uplifting this, that, or the other. One shudders slightly
and turns to the impeccable style, the slightly tired and sensuous
irony of Anatole France (not yet censored, if we read him in French)
for relief. Or if we are so fortunate as to be “regular” Americans
instead of unhappy intellectuals educated beyond our environment,
we go gratefully back to our work at the office. Beside the stilted
artificiality of this world of higher ethical values the business
world, where men haggle, cheat, and steal with whole-hearted devotion
is at least real. And it is this world, the world of making money,
in which alone the American man can feel thoroughly at home. If the
French romanticists of the 18th century invented the phrase _la femme
mécomprise_, a modern Gallic visitor would be tempted to observe
that in this 20th century the United States was the land of _l’homme
mécompris_.
These, then, are the cruder historical forces that have led directly
to the present remarkable situation, a situation, of course, which I
attempt to depict only in its larger outlines. For the surface of the
contemporary social structure shows us suffrage, the new insights into
the world of industry which the war gave so many women for the first
time, the widening of professional opportunity, co-education, and, in
the life which perhaps those of us who have contributed to this volume
know best, a genuine intellectual camaraderie. Nevertheless, I believe
the underlying thesis cannot be successfully challenged. Where men
and women in America to-day share their intellectual life on terms of
equality and perfect understanding, closer examination reveals that
the phenomenon is not a sharing but a capitulation. The men have been
feminized.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account