Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
If from single individuals we turn to consider currents of scientific
thought, the United States again stands the trial with flying colours.
It can hardly be denied that in a number of branches our countrymen
are marching in the vanguard. “Experimental biology,” said a German
zoologist some time before the War, “is pre-eminently an American
science.” Certainly one need merely glance at German or British
manuals to learn how deeply interpretations of basic evolutionary
phenomena have been affected by the work of Professor T. H. Morgan
and his followers. In psychology it is true that no one wears the
mantle of William James, but there is effective advancement along
a number of distinct lines. Thorndike’s tests marked an era in the
annals of animal psychology, supplanting with a saner technique the
slovenly work of earlier investigators. Experimental investigation of
mental phenomena generally, of individual variability and behaviour in
particular, flourishes in a number of academic centres. In anthropology
the writings of Lewis H. Morgan have proved a tremendous stimulus to
sociological speculation the world over and still retain their hold
on many European thinkers. They were not, in my opinion, the product
of a great intellect and the scheme of evolution traced by Morgan is
doomed to abandonment. Yet his theories have suggested a vast amount
of thought and to his lasting credit it must be said that he opened
up an entirely new and fruitful field of recondite research through
his painstaking accumulation and discussion of primitive kinship
terminologies.
More recently the anthropological school headed by Professor Boas has
led to a transvaluation of theoretical values in the study of cultural
development, supplanting with a sounder historical insight the cruder
evolutionary speculation of the past. Above all, its founder has
succeeded in perfecting the methodology of every division of the vast
subject, and remains probably the only anthropologist in the world who
has both directly and indirectly furthered ethnological, linguistic,
somatological and archæological investigation. Finally, the active part
played by pathologists like Dr. Simon Flexner in the experimental study
of disease is too well known to require more than brief mention.
Either in its individual or collective results, American research is
thus very far from being a negligible factor in the scientific life of
the world. Nevertheless, the medal has a reverse side, and he would be
a bold optimist who should sincerely voice complete contentment either
with the status of science in the cultural polity of the nation or with
the work achieved by the average American investigator. Let us, then,
try to face the less flattering facts in the case.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account