Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
Within philosophy, the most radical expression of this attitude appears
in the New Realism, and in the instrumentalism of Dewey. In 1910,
six of the younger American philosophers issued in the _Journal of
Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Method_ “The Programme and First
Platform of Six Realists,” followed shortly by a co-operative volume
of studies to elaborate the doctrine. Their deepest bond of union is
a distaste for the romantic spirit and obscurantist logic of Absolute
Idealism. Hence their dominant idea is to cut at the very foundations
of this system, the theory of relations in general, and the relation
of idea and object in particular. Young America is not fond of the
subtleties of history, hence these realists take their stand upon the
“unimpeachable truth of the accredited results of science” at a time
when, by the irony of history, science herself has begun to doubt.
To thwart idealism, psychology must be rewritten. While consciousness
exists there is always the chance that our world of facts may fade into
subjective presentations. Seizing a fruitful suggestion of James’, they
introduce us to a world of objects that exists quite independently
of being known. The relations of these objects are external to them
and independent of their character. Sometimes, however, there arise
relations between our organisms and other objects that can best be
described by asserting that these objects have entered into our
consciousness. How then can we fall into error? Only as nature makes
mistakes, by reacting in a way that brings conflict with unnoted
conditions. Perhaps the greatest contribution of Realism as yet to
American thought is the contribution of some of its apostles to its
implicit psychology, already independently established as behaviourism,
the most vital movement in contemporary psychology.
The highly technical form of the Six Realists’ co-operative volume has
kept their doctrine from any great reading public. But in its critical
echoes, the busy American finds a sympathetic note in the assertion
of the independent reality of the objects with which he works and the
world in which he has to make his way. His also is practical faith
in science, and he is glad to escape an inevitable type of religion
and moral theory to be swallowed along with philosophy. Until the New
Realists, however, develop further implications of their theory, or
at least present congenial religious, moral, and social attitudes,
their philosophy has only the negative significance of release. If it
is going to take a deep hold on life, it must also be creative, not
replacing dogma by dogma, but elaborating some new world vision. As yet
it has told us little more than that truth, goodness, and beauty are
independent realities, eternal subsistencies that await our discovery.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account