Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
Such openness of interest forefends the possibility of James’ founding
a school of philosophy. It also renders all his younger contemporaries
in some measure his disciples. Popularly he is the refuge of the
mystics and heterodox, the spiritualists and the cranks who seek the
sanction of academic scholarship and certified dignity. There are
more things in the philosophies of these who call him master than are
dreamed of in his philosophy. In academic philosophy there is a dual
descent of the James tradition. As a principle of negative criticism,
it may be turned into its opposite, as with Hocking, who enunciates
the extreme form of the pragmatic principle, If a theory is not
interesting, it is false--and utilizes it for his realistic, mystic,
idealistic absolutism. The philosophy of Henri Bergson, that has been
widely read in this country, reinforces this mystical spiritual side,
but American mysticism has popularly tended to degenerate into the
occultisms of second-rate credulous minds.
On the other hand, for those in whom the conflict of science and
religion is settling itself on the side of science, the principle of
pragmatism lends itself to the interpretation originally intended by
Charles Peirce, the author of the term, as an experimentalism, a search
for verifiable hypotheses after the manner of the sciences. But this
side of the doctrine is the one that has been developed by John Dewey.
Professor Dewey is without question the leading American philosopher,
both from the thoroughness of his analyses and the vigour of his appeal
to the American public. In discarding the Hegelian Idealism in which
he was trained, he is thoroughly aligned with the New America. In him
science has wholly won, and although of New England, Vermont, ancestry,
there remains not a trace of the New Englander’s romantic spiritual
longings for contact with a vast unknown. His dogmatic faiths, and no
man is without such faiths, relate to evolution, democracy, and the
all-decisive authority of experience.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account