Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
relief the essential infantility of the American writer as we know the
type. By what prodigies of alert self-adaptation, of discriminating
self-scrutiny, of conscious effort does the creative will come into its
own! As for us, weak as too many of us are, ignorant, isolated, all too
easily satisfied, and scarcely as yet immune from the solicitations of
the mob, we still have this advantage, that an age of reaction is an
age that stirs the few into a consciousness of themselves.
VAN WYCK BROOKS
MUSIC
We spend more money upon music than does any other nation on earth;
some of our orchestras, notably those of Boston, Chicago, and
Philadelphia, are worthy to rank among the world’s best; in the
Metropolitan Opera House we give performances of grand opera that for
consistent excellence of playing, singing, and _mise-en-scène_ are
surpassed probably nowhere. Yet there has never been a successful opera
by an American offered at that opera house, and the number of viable
American orchestral works is small enough to be counted almost upon
one’s fingers. We squander millions every year upon an art that we
cannot produce.
There are apologists for the American composer who will say that we
do produce it, but that it is strangled at birth. According to their
stock argument, there are numberless greatly gifted native composers
whose works never get a hearing, (a) because Americans are prejudiced
against American music and in favour of foreign music, and (b) because
the foreigners who largely control the musical situation in this
country jealously refuse to allow American works to be performed.
This would be impressive if it were consistent or true. As far as
concerns the Jealous Foreigner myth--he does not dominate the musical
situation--I have never noticed that the average European in this
country is deficient either in self-interest or tact. He is generally
anxious, if only for diplomatic reasons, to find American music that
is worth singing or playing. Even when he fails to find any that is
worth performing, he often performs some that isn’t, in order to
satisfy local pride. Moreover, Americans are no more prejudiced against
American musicians than they are against other kinds. As a matter of
fact, if intensive boosting campaigns produced creative artists, the
American composer during the past decade should have expanded like
a hot-house strawberry. We have had prize contests of all kinds,
offering substantial sums for everything from grand operas to string
quartettes, we have had societies formed to publish his chamber-music
scores; publishers have rushed to print his smaller works; we have had
concerts of American compositions; we have had all-American festivals.
Meanwhile the American composer has, with a few lonely exceptions,
obstinately refused to produce anything above the level of what it
would be flattering to call mediocrity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account