Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
Such failure to make adequate use of his ideas is partially
attributable to the American musician’s pathetically inadequate
technical equipment. Generally speaking, he doesn’t know his business.
He has been unable, or hasn’t bothered, to learn his trade. Imagine if
you can a successful dramatist who can neither read nor write, but has
to dictate his plays, or a painter who can only draw the outlines of
his pictures, hiring some one else to lay in the colours, and you have
something analogous to many an American “composer” whose music is taken
seriously by Americans, and who cannot write out a playable piano part,
arrange a song for choral performance, or transcribe a hymn tune for
a string quartette. Such elementary work he has to have done for him,
whenever it is necessary, by some hack. This, to say nothing of the
more advanced branches of musical science, like counterpoint, fugue,
orchestration. Though it is risky to generalize, it is probably safe
to say that among Americans who write music, the man who can construct
a respectable fugue or canon or score a piece for full orchestra is
decidedly the exception. In Europe, of course, any man who did not
have these technical resources at his fingertips would have to be a
Moussorgsky to be taken seriously as a composer at all.
It is not entirely the American’s fault that he is so ill-equipped.
Much of his comparative musical illiteracy, true, is the result of
his own laziness and his traditional American contempt for theory and
passion for results. On the other hand, the young American who honestly
desires a good theoretical training in music must either undertake
the expensive adventure of journeying to one of the few cities that
contain a first-class conservatory, or the equally expensive one of
going to Europe. If he can do neither, he must to a great extent
educate himself. Some kinds of training it is nearly impossible for
him to obtain here at any price. Orchestration, for instance, a
tremendously complex and difficult science, can be mastered only by
the time-honoured trial and error method, i.e., by writing out scores
and hearing them played. How is our young American to manage this?
Granted that there is a symphony orchestra near him, how can he get
his scores played? The conductor cannot be blamed for refusing. He
is hired to play the works of masters, not to try out the apprentice
efforts of unskilled aspirants. What we need so badly here are not
more first-class orchestras, but more second-rate ones, small-town
orchestras that could afford to give the tyro a chance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account