Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
Let me be platitudinous in the interest of clarity and point out what
we so often forget: that our nation, unlike most of the others, is not
a race as well. We have common wellsprings of thought, but--and this
is significant and ominous--none of feeling. Sheer environment may
teach people to think alike within a generation; but it takes centuries
of common emotional experiences to make them feel alike. Any average
American, even of the National-Security-League-one-hundred-per-centum
variety, may have in his veins the blood of English, French, Italian,
and Russian ancestors, and there is no saying that his emotional
nature is going to find many heart-beats in common with some equally
average neighbour, whose ancestry may be, say, Irish, Danish, and
Hungarian. What national spirit we have has been determined, first,
by the fact that the ancestors of every one of us, whether they came
here twenty years ago or two hundred, were pioneers. Every one of them
left a civilization whose cultural background had been established for
centuries, to come to a land where the problem of mere existence was
of prime importance. Again, many of them were religious fanatics. In
the life of the pioneer there was little room for art of any sort, and
least for music. What he demanded of music, when he had time to spare
for it, was that above all things it distract him from the fatigue
and worry of everyday life, either by amusing him or by furnishing a
sentimental reminder of old ways. To the Puritan, music, both for its
own sake and as entertainment, was anathema. As sensuous beauty it was
popish, and as entertainment it was worldly pleasure, and therefore
wicked. To be tolerated at all, it must be practical, i.e., perform
some moral service by being a hymn tune. And what the American pioneer
and the American Puritan asked a few generations back, the average
American asks to-day whenever he is confronted with any work of art:
Does it point a moral? If not, will it help me to kill time without
boring me?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account