Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
essentials after the years in which people were deprived of them.
Another phenomenon to be noted at this point is the dominance of women
in American art-matters. It is unknown in any other country. The vast
majority of American men are engrossed in the drive of work, their
leisure goes to sport and to the forms of entertainment that call for
the smallest amount of mental effort. The women, with their quicker
sensibility and their recognition of art as one of the things that
mark the higher orders of life, take over the furnishing of the home
and through this and the study that their greater leisure permits
them, exert a strong influence on the purchase of art-works for
private collections and even museums. The production of the American
painter and sculptor is also much affected as a consequence, and in
the direction of conventionality. I do not claim that the level of art
in America would be greatly improved at present if it were the men
instead of the women who took the lead; perhaps, in view of the state
of appreciation in our people, it would be lowered; but I maintain that
the fact that art is so much in the hands of women and the suspicion
among men that it carries with it some implication of effeminacy are
among the indications of American immaturity in art-appreciation. We
cannot expect an art really representative of America until there is a
foundation of regard for his work that the artist can build on. In the
old civilizations the artist was meeting an active demand on the part
of his people; in America, he has to seek desperately for a living.
Albrecht Dürer summed up the difference between the two states of
civilization when he wrote from Venice to a friend in the young Germany
of his day: “Oh, how I shall freeze for this sun when I get home; here
I am a gentleman, at home a parasite.”
It will seem to many that even such famous words should not be repeated
in a country where art is so often mentioned in the papers, where
museums are springing up in large numbers, where unheard-of prices
are paid for the work of famous men, and where even those who take
no interest in art will accord it a sort of halo. But the very fact
that it is relegated to the class of Sunday things instead of entering
into everyday life shows that our colonial period--in the cultural
sense of the word--is not yet passed. This should not be looked on as
discouraging; it is natural that the formation of character and ideas
should require time and I shall endeavour to show that the development
is really a rapid and healthy one. The mistake Americans are most prone
to, that of imagining the country to have reached a mature character
and a valid expression, shows their eagerness to advance, and explains
their readiness to tear down or to build up.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account