Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
No, the fault is not with the managers and producers, but with the
playwrights. The latter, where they are not mere parrots, are cowards.
Young and old, new and experienced, talented and talentless alike, they
are in the mass so many _Saturday Evening Post_ souls, alone dreaming
of and intent upon achieving a sufficient financial gain to transmute
the Ford into a Rolls-Royce and the Hudson Bay seal collar into Russian
sable. A baby cannot be nourished and developed physically upon water;
a theatrical public, for all its potential willingness, cannot be
developed aesthetically upon a diet of snide writing. In the American
theatre of the present time there are not more than two, or at most
three, playwrights out of all the hundreds, who retain in their hearts
a determined and uncorrupted purpose. Take away young O’Neill, and give
a bit of ground to Miss Rita Wellman (whose accomplishment is still
too vague for fixed appraisal), and there is next to nothing left.
Flashes of talent, yes, but only flashes. Craven’s “Too Many Cooks”
and “The First Year” are observant, highly skilful depictions of the
American scene, but they are dramatic literature only in the degree
that “Main Street” and “This Side of Paradise” are literature. With
the extraordinary “Papa,” Miss Zoë Akins gave up and surrendered--at
least temporarily--to the box-office skull and cross-bones. Until
Tarkington proves that “Clarence” was not a happy accident in the
long and unbroken line of “Up from Nowhere,” “Mister Antonio,” “The
Country Cousin,” “The Alan from Home,” “Cameo Kirby,” “Your Humble
Servant,” “Springtime,” “Getting a Polish,” “The Gibson Upright,” and
“Poldekin,” we shall have to hold up our decision on him. George Ade,
the great promise of authentic American drama, is no more; he pulled
in his oars, alas, in mid-stream. Joseph Medill Patterson, an honest
dramatist, fell through the bridge while not yet half way across. The
rest? Well, the rest are the Augustus Thomases, left-overs from the
last generation, proficient technicians with empty heads, or youngsters
still dramatically wet behind the ears. The rest of the rest? Ticket
salesmen.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account