Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
General
Civilization in the United States: An inquiry by thirty Americans
United States -- Civilization
“Are you, O Author,” so they speak, “quite fair when you pronounce
these bitter words? Are we not all human--too human? Is it reasonable
to demand of our historians that they shall possess such qualities of
detached judgment as have not been seen on this earth since the last
of the Mighty Gods departed from High Olympus? Has a historian no
heart? Do you expect him to stand by and discuss the virtues of vague
political questions, when all the world is doing its bit--while his
children are risking their lives for the safety of the common land?”
And when we are approached in this way, we find it difficult to answer
“no.” For we too are an animated compound of prejudice and unreasonable
preferences and even more unreasoning dislikes, and we do not like to
assume the rôle of both judge and jury.
The evidence, however, gives us no chance to decide otherwise. What
was done in the heat of battle--what was done under the stress of
great and sincere emotions--what was written in the agony of a thousand
fears--all that will be forgotten within a few years. But enough will
remain to convince our grandchildren that the historian was among those
most guilty of creating that “state of mind” without which modern
warfare would be an impossibility.
Here the music of the flutes grows silent. The Chorus steps back
and the main action of our little play continues. The time is “the
present” and the problem is “the future.” The children who are now in
the second grade will be called upon to bear the burden of a very long
period of reconstruction. America, their home, has been compared to an
exceedingly powerful and influential woman who is not very popular but
who must not be offended on account of her eminent social position. The
folk who live along our international Main Street are not very well
disposed towards a neighbour who holds all the mortgages and lives in
the only house that has managed to survive the recent catastrophe. It
will not be an easy thing to maintain the peace in the neurasthenic
community of the great post-war period. It has been suggested that the
Ten Commandments, when rightly applied, may help us through the coming
difficulties. We beg to suggest that a thorough knowledge of the past
will prove to be quite as useful as the Decalogue. We do not make this
statement hastily. Furthermore, we qualify it by the observation that
both History and the Decalogue will be only two of a great many other
remedies that will have to be applied if the world is to be set free
from its present nightmare of poison gas and high-velocity shells. But
we insist that History be included. And we do so upon the statement of
a learned and famous colleague who passed through a most disastrous
war and yet managed to keep a cool head. We mean Thucydides. In his
foreword to the History of the Peloponnesian War he wrote: “The absence
of romance in my history will, I fear, detract somewhat from its
interest; but if it be judged by those inquirers who desire an exact
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account