It would appear, however, that this is not what is meant after all. What Dr. Carpenter apparently means is this: when a quantity of water, say a layer one foot thick, flows down from the equator to the pole, the polar column becomes then heavier than the equatorial by the weight of this additional layer. A layer of water equal in quantity is therefore pressed away from the bottom of the column and flows off in the direction of the equator as an under current, the polar column at the same time sinking down one foot until equilibrium of the polar and equatorial columns is restored. Another foot of water now flows down upon the polar column and another foot of water is displaced from below, causing, of course, the column to descend an additional foot. The same process being continually repeated, a constant downward motion of the polar column is the result. Or, perhaps, to express the matter more accurately, owing to the constant flow of water from the equatorial regions down the slope, the weight of the polar column is kept always in excess of that of the equatorial; therefore the polar column in the effort to restore equilibrium is kept in a constant state of descent. Hence he terms it a “vertical” circulation. The following will show Dr. Carpenter’s theory in his own words:— “The action of cold on the surface water of each polar area will be exerted as follows:— “(_a_) In diminishing the height of the polar column as compared with that of the equatorial, so that a lowering of its _level_ is produced, which can only be made good by a surface-flow from the latter towards the former. “(_b_) In producing an excess in the downward _pressure_ of the column when this inflow has restored its level, in virtue of the increase of specific gravity it has gained by its reduction in volume; whereby a portion of its heavy bottom-water is displaced laterally, causing a further reduction of level, which draws in a further supply of the warmer and lighter water flowing towards its surface. “(_c_) In imparting a downward _movement_ to each new surface-stratum as its temperature undergoes reduction; so that the _entire column_ may be said to be in a state of constant descent, like that which exists in the water of a tall jar when an opening is made at its bottom, and the water which flows away through it is replaced by an equivalent supply poured into the top of the jar” (§ 23). But if this be his theory, as it evidently is, then the 4 foot-pounds (the amount of work performed by the descent of the water down the slope) comprehends all the work that gravitation can perform on a pound of water in making a complete circuit from the equator to the pole and from the pole back to the equator.