Corruption in American politics and lifeBrooks, Robert C. (Robert Clarkson)
History
Corruption in American politics and life
Brooks, Robert C. (Robert Clarkson)
Political corruption -- United States; United States -- Social conditions -- 1865-1918
In comparing the political morality of Europe and America reference
must finally be made, even at the risk of repetition, to the greater
political trust imposed in the mass of our people. As regards the
number participating suffrage is not materially different in the United
States from the systems of the leading European nations. The tendency
abroad, however, is to limit the direct popular vote to legislative
offices only and to the smallest possible number of these. It is
undeniable that we have gone too far in the opposite direction. We
crowd not only legislative but also many judicial and administrative
offices on our “blanket” ballots, and as a result the total number of
places submitted to the popular vote passes all bounds. Instead of
realising greater democracy by this method we enable the machine to
take advantage of the confusion which the elector feels when confronted
by so many places and candidates, and his consequent inclination to
vote “straight.”[114] Apart from this point, however, it is extremely
important to note that the power of the vote to confer place is much
greater in the United States than abroad, and consequently, if it is
to be corruptly purchased or misused, its value is higher. To put
the matter in another way, the trust imposed by the Republic in the
voter is greater. The number of offices to which the ordinary citizen
is eligible by ballot without regard to class standing or desirable
preparation, the greater importance of state and local government,
and the placing of the latter under popular control,—all contribute
to increase the burden of responsibility which is imposed upon
the great mass. We must admit that the trust thus created is often
violated, but on the other hand we deserve such credit as may arise
from the fact that we have deliberately chosen to believe in the
virtue of the whole people and have established a system which puts
that virtue to a supreme test. European nations which take the “holier
than thou” attitude with reference to our corruption might be forced
to abandon their pretensions if they were to lodge as much power in
their electorates as we do in ours. Given two communities, one “dry”
and the other “wet,” the mere fact that there was more drunkenness in
the latter would not prove a less degree of moral control of appetite
on the part of its inhabitants. One would have to take into account
that the citizens of the “wet” community could satisfy their thirst
openly and frequently, whereas some of the “drys” must be sober at
times simply because they cannot get liquor. On the other hand, those
citizens of the “wet” community who abstain must do so of their own
volition and in the face of constant temptation. Similarly it may be
said of the political vice existing in the United States that its
magnitude is in part due to the fact that, loving democracy “not
wisely but too well,” we have distributed powers and responsibilities
broadcast with the consequence that they have fallen partly into
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account