Creation or Evolution? A Philosophical InquiryCurtis, George Ticknor
Religion
Creation or Evolution? A Philosophical Inquiry
Curtis, George Ticknor
Creation; Evolution
[77] Mr. Spencer observes that the hypothesis of special creations is
one "which formulates absolute ignorance into a semblance of positive
knowledge...." Thus, however regarded, the hypothesis of special
creations turns out to be worthless--worthless by its derivation;
worthless in its intrinsic incoherence; worthless as absolutely
without evidence; worthless as not satisfying a moral want. "We must
therefore consider it as counting for nothing, in opposition to any
other hypothesis respecting the origin of organic beings." There is a
great deal more in the same tone. (See "Biology," i, pp. 344, 345, and
_passim_ throughout Chapters II and III of Part III of that work.) Mr.
Darwin, who is sufficiently positive, is much more moderate, and in my
opinion a much better reasoner, although I can not subscribe to his
reasoning or his conclusions. A rather irreverent naval officer of my
acquaintance once extolled a doctrinal sermon, which he had just heard
preached by a Unitarian clergyman, in this fashion: "I tell you what,
sir, the preacher did not leave the Trinity a leg to stand upon."
Probably some of Mr. Spencer's readers think that he has equally
demolished the doctrine of special creations.
[78] "Descent of Man," p. 155.
CHAPTER VI.
The doctrine of evolution, according to Herbert Spencer, further
considered.
In the last two preceding chapters I have examined what Mr. Spencer
regards as the direct supports of the doctrine of evolution. I have now
to consider the different orders of facts which, as he claims, yield to
it indirect support. These are the facts derived from classification,
from embryology, from morphology, and from distribution. An explanation
is here needful of the sense in which he uses these respective terms,
before the reader, who is not accustomed to them, is called upon to
understand and appreciate the argument:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account