Creation or Evolution? A Philosophical InquiryCurtis, George Ticknor
Religion
Creation or Evolution? A Philosophical Inquiry
Curtis, George Ticknor
Creation; Evolution
Along with these phenomena of distribution in space and in medium of
life, we have the further element of distribution in time; the facts
of which are admitted, however, to be too fragmentary to be conclusive
either for or against the doctrine of evolution. Still it is claimed
that there is one general truth respecting distribution in time,
which is "profoundly significant, namely, that the relations between
the extinct forms of life, found by geological exploration, and the
present forms of life, especially in each great geographical region,
show in the aggregate a close kinship, and a connection which is in
perfect harmony with the belief in evolution, but quite irreconcilable
with any other belief. As Mr. Darwin has expressed it, there is 'a
wonderful relationship in the same continent between the living and the
dead.'"[91]
The argument from distribution is thus summed up by Mr. Spencer:
Given, then, that pressure which species exercise on one another,
in consequence of the universal overfilling of their respective
habitats--given the resulting tendency to thrust themselves into one
another's areas, and media, and modes of life, along such lines of
least resistance as from time to time are found--given, besides the
changes in modes of life hence arising, those other changes which
physical alterations of habitats necessitate--given the structural
modifications directly or indirectly produced in organisms by modified
conditions--and the facts of distribution in space and time are
accounted for. That divergence and redivergence of organic forms,
which we saw to be shadowed forth by the truths of classification
and the truths of embryology, we see to be also shadowed forth by
the truths of distribution. If that aptitude to multiply, to spread,
to separate, and to differentiate, which the human races have in
all times shown, be a tendency common to races in general, as we
have ample reason to assume, then there will result that kind of
relation among the species, and genera, and orders, peopling the
earth's surface, which we find exists. Those remarkable identities
of type discovered between organisms inhabiting one medium, and
strangely-modified organisms inhabiting another medium, are at
the same time rendered comprehensible. And the appearances and
disappearances of species which the geological record shows us, as
well as the connections between successive groups of species from
early eras down to our own, cease to be inexplicable.[92]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account