Criminality and economic conditionsBonger, Willem Adriaan
General
Criminality and economic conditions
Bonger, Willem Adriaan
Crime -- Economic aspects
Not only does poverty predispose to crime, but it also furnishes the
motives for it. Leading to alcoholism it is the cause of violent
crimes; it drives persons who cannot find work to vagrancy and
mendicity, which in their turn are the preparatory school for greater
crimes; it puts the great number of those who cannot provide honestly
for their needs to the necessity of stealing. And when these factors
act upon a man already predisposed, they even lead as far as homicide.
In the following table the different Italian districts, as well as the
crimes committed, have been grouped about their average figures.
Wealth. Crimes.
(3.333) Latium VII --
-- VI --
-- V --
(2.747) Piedmont-Liguria IV --
(2.400) Lombardy III --
-- II --
} { Lombardy (649)
} { Tuscany (710)
(2.164) Tuscany } I { Piedmont-Liguria (732)
} { Emilia (749)
} { Marches-Umbria (774)
(1.935) Venice } { Venice (857)
(1.876) Kingdom } Average. { Kingdom (926)
(1.762) Emilia } { Sicily (1021)
-- 1st Naples (1150)
(1.471) Sicily } {
(1.333) Naples } 2d { Sardinia (1440)
(1.227) Marches-Umbria 3d --
Sardinia 4th Latium (1797)
According to the author it appears from this table that, with the
exception of Latium, the districts with wealth above the average have a
number of crimes below the average. Nevertheless the regions with a
figure for wealth above the average, i.e. Piedmont-Liguria, Lombardy,
and Latium, show a greater number of crimes than one would expect,
while Sicily, Naples, Marches-Umbria, and Sardinia show lower figures
for crime than would be supposed. This contradiction is only apparent,
according to the author, and is to be explained as follows: first,
because where there is wealth there is also poverty and frequent
opportunities to steal; second, because dangerous individuals migrate
less to districts where there is less wealth; third, because, as John
Stuart Mill says, it results from the social conditions of our day that
the education of the poor is nil and that of the rich bad.
The second chapter, having as its title, “Il fattore economico e la
delinquenza.—Dinamica”, contains some data upon the trend of
criminality in the period in question. Criminality in general is
increasing; serious crimes remain nearly stationary, while less serious
crimes increase. As Ferri observes, criminality is decreasing, even in
Italy, as to its intensity and violence, but increasing as to its
extent.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account