(3) No appointments to positions shall be made before the scheme of this commission has been approved. DEFERRING TAKING OVER CERTAIN IRISH SERVICES. Arrangements to be made to permit the Irish Government, if they so desire, to defer taking over the services relating to Old-Age Pensions, National Insurance, Labor Exchanges, Post Office Trustee Savings Banks, and Friendly Societies. (43 to 18.) The final division on the question of the adoption of the report as a whole was as follows: FOR (44) E. H. Andrews M. K. Barry J. Bolger W. Broderick J. Butler J. J. Clancy J. J. Coen D. Condren P. Dempsey Earl of Desart J. Dooly Captain Doran Archbishop of Dublin Lord Mayor of Dublin T. Fallon J. Fitzgibbon Sir W. Goulding M. Governey Earl of Granard Captain Gwynn T. Halligan A. Jameson W. Kavanagh Alderman McCarron M. McDonogh J. McDonnell C. McKay A. R. MacMullen Viscount Midleton J. Murphy J. O'Dowd C. P. O'Neill Lord Oranmore and Browne Dr. O'Sullivan J. B. Powell T. Power Provost of Trinity College Sir S. B. Quin D. Reilly M. Slattery G. F. Stewart R. Waugh H. T. Whitley Sir B. Windle AGAINST (29) Duke of Abercorn Sir R. N. Anderson H. B. Armstrong H. T. Barrie Lord Mayor of Belfast Archbishop of Cashel Sir G. Clark Colonel J. J. Clark Lord Mayor of Cork Colonel Sharman-Crawford Bishop of Down and Connor T. Duggan H. Garahan J. Hanna M. E. Knight Marquis of Londonderry J. S. McCance Sir C. McCullagh J. McGarry H. G. MacGeagh J. McHugh Moderator General Assembly W. M. Murphy P. O'H. Peters H. M. Pollock Bishop of Raphoe T. Toal Colonel Wallace Sir W. Whitla ULSTER UNIONISTS' REPORT Nineteen Ulster Unionists signed a dissenting report in which they declared that it had soon become evident to them that no real approach to agreement was possible, as the Nationalists put it beyond doubt that what they wanted was "full national independence," or a Parliament possessing co-equal powers with those of the Imperial Parliament. If the Ulster Unionists had anticipated this at the outset, their report explained, they "could not have agreed to enter the convention." Objection was taken to the Nationalist scheme, which aimed at denying the right of the Imperial Parliament to impose military service in Ireland "unless with the consent of the proposed Irish Parliament." Dr. Mahaffy, Provost of Trinity College, Dublin, and the Archbishop of Armagh, in a separate note, stated that they found it impossible to vote for the majority proposals, since these involved, in their opinion, either the coercion of Ulster, which was unthinkable, or the partition of Ireland, which would be disastrous.