_In Semi-Diameters of Earth._
Moon 64⅛
Mercury 167
Venus 1120
Sun 1220
Mars 8876
Jupiter 14,405
Saturn and Stars 20,110
In this, the moon’s distance is approximately correct, but the sun’s
is not much more than one-twentieth of its true value. To set the
stars at a distance of only twenty thousand times Earth’s semi-diameter
seems to us to bring them very close,[67] but they would still be
beyond measurement by naked eye methods, so it is no contradiction to
Alfraganus’ earlier statement that Earth is a point compared with the
heavens.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[67] Earth’s diameter, and even Earth’s distance from the sun, is too
small a unit. Light, travelling 186,000 miles a second, takes 4¼ years
to reach us from the nearest star.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Arabs also believed that they had succeeded in measuring the
apparent diameters of the planets and even of the points of light which
are all we can see of stars, so Alfraganus gives the accepted sizes of
all. I give them below in descending order of size. The modern values
in the third column show how false were the results obtained by this
mistaken method.
DIAMETER: EARTH = 1.
_Alfraganus. Modern Values._
Sun 5½ 109½
The 15 first-magnitude { Arcturus, Sirius,
stars 4¾ { Spica, and others, much
{ larger than the sun.
Jupiter 4⁹/₁₆ 11
Saturn 4½ 9
Other stars, in order of { Various. Some certainly
magnitude, 2nd to 6th ... { larger than the sun.
Mars 1⅛ ½
Earth 1 1
Venus ³/₁₀ ⁹/₁₀
Moon ⁵/₁₇ ¼
Mercury ¹/₁₈ ⅓
In the above table the size of the moon (whose parallax had been found
by the Greeks) is the only one which is nearly right. The sun is far
too small, and so are the stars. We cannot yet know with certainty the
diameter of any star, but they are all comparable with the sun, and
many are enormously larger.[68] As their distances are all different,
some of the brightest may be comparatively small, and some of the
faintest the largest of all.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account