A calculation based on the difference in latitude between Rome and the
Straits shows that they are only about 9° south of west, and that the
sun, when setting in this direction is about 6° south of the equator:
this is the case 15 days after the equinox, which in the beginning
of the fourteenth century fell on September 14. Therefore the date
at which the sun was seen from Rome setting in the direction between
Sardinia and Corsica was the 29th of September, and its position in the
zodiac was then the middle of the sign Libra. (Owing to precession,
it would be in the _constellation_ Virgo, but we have seen that Dante
ignores precession in these references.)
But the moon ought now, on this second night in Purgatory, to
have reached at least the last degrees of Scorpio, since on the
previous night she rose when the first part was already above the
horizon. Dante has therefore made a flagrant mistake with his moon,
running her back into Libra again, and falsifying all his previous
descriptions—_if_ he knew as much about geography as we do now. But it
is only necessary to glance at the map of Henry of Mainz to see that
such a supposition would be grotesque. The portolan maps did indeed
show the relative positions of Rome, Sardinia, and Corsica, with
remarkable accuracy;[474] but as we have already said, it is not in
the least likely that Dante had ever seen one of these sailing charts.
It was on the classics, and especially on Orosius, that he relied
for his geography,[475] and the suggestion of Dr. Moore seems most
plausible, that he was here thinking of the Spaniard’s description of
Sardinia:—“Habet _ab oriente et borea_ Tyrrenicum mare quod spectat ad
portum urbis Romae.”[476] This implies that Sardinia lay south-west of
Rome, in a direction such as the sun might have had when setting in
November, in Scorpio or Sagittarius.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
[474] See for instance the “Carte Pisane,“ and the Central
Mediterranean map of Vesconte, dating from about 1300 and 1311
respectively, in Beazley’s _Dawn of Geography_, iii. Latitudes and
longitudes are not given, but from certain centres lines radiate to all
points of the compass, like great spiders’ webs.
[475] _De Mon._ II. iii. 87-90. etc.
[476] “It is bounded _on the east and north_ by the Tyrrhenian sea,
which lies towards the port of Rome,” Moore, _Studies in Dante_ iii. p.
72.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Or possibly, when the poet was in Rome in 1301, he may have been
watching a sunset in the second week in November, and may have been
told, among other pieces of misinformation which are so readily given
to visitors to great cities, that he was looking towards the straits
which separate Sardinia from Corsica. We can imagine his replying, or
thinking: “Then the sun sets behind them when he has nearly finished
his course in Scorpio, and is about to yoke his steeds under another
star!”[477]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account