Now note the importance of what follows. Neither side in the struggle of
the autumn had definitely won. The National Assembly had temporised, the
advantage of the Cordeliers in the matter of the disputed elections had
been achieved by a trick, and in the dead-lock between two principles,
the central power of the Municipality and the local autonomy of the
district, neither of the two theories was based upon tradition, neither
even (in the confusion of rapid reforms) could justify itself by a
definite pronouncement of the law. On the one side was the theory of
a highly restricted suffrage, government by a class socially refined
and lying with the nobility rather than with the people; this side was
determined to form an army to support their politics, and it was they
who, when they did act at last, achieved—but much too late—the sharp and
sanguinary reaction of July 1791. On the other side was the desire for
a wide, later for a universal, suffrage; a determination to emphasise
in the development of the Revolutionary theory, equality and the
general will, rather than order and the practical working of new laws;
a political attitude which was to lead the Revolution into the intense
idealism of 1792, and to end by declaring the Republic. And all this
was represented in the demand which, of its nature, is the expression
of extreme democracy—I mean the demand for local autonomy, the idea
that an act of government is most just when it emanates not even from
representatives, but from the lips of the governed themselves.
Such were the two forces opposed to one another in the affair of
Marat—forces which, if not in all France, were in Paris at least the two
great camps of the Revolution. Already the district had declared its
intention to protect the liberty of the press within its boundaries,[64]
and had been wise enough to specially condemn Marat’s violence; already
had it named a committee of five to see that no arbitrary arrest should
take place in its territory,[65] when Lafayette sent his militia, cavalry
and infantry, on the 22nd of January to help the arrest of Marat. Not
content with the 3000 men thus employed, he clinched the matter with
cannon, placing a couple of pieces at the end of the Rue des Fossés St.
Germains.[66] He was determined to settle things by force, and beat the
extremists with their own weapons. His effort did not find force opposed
to it, as he had hoped; it broke itself in the most unexpected manner
upon the legal ability of Danton.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account