A
: this is the most literal translation; GUO has
Thus you are prepared in
advance
[early]
B : literally “your extremes”,
presumably in the sense of “to what extremes you will go” or “how far will
you go”; compare to #58
Cross-references
possess or take hold of the
world or nation :
#29, #48, #57, #61
mother : #1, #20, #25, #52
can forever endure : #44
Chapter Sixty
治 大 國 若 烹 小 鮮
以 道
莅 天 下
其 鬼
不 神
非 其
鬼 不 神 •
其 神
不 傷 人 •
非 其
神 不 傷
人 •
聖 人
亦 不 傷
人 •
夫 兩
不 相 傷
(•)故 德 交 歸 焉
Governing a great nation is
like cooking a small fish.
Because Dao is present in
the world,
Its ghosts do not have
spirit.
Not that its ghosts do not
have any spirit,
But their spirit does not
injure people.
Not only does their spirit
not injure people,
The sage also does not
injure people.
Now : since these two do
not injure each other,
Therefore their De merges
and returns!
♦Governing a great
nation is like cooking a small fish.A
♦Because Dao
is present in the world2,
♦Its ghosts
do not have spirit.B
♦Not that its
ghosts do not have [any] spirit,
♦But their spirit
does not injure people.
♦Not [only]
does their spirit not injure people,
The sage2
also does not injure people.
♦Now : since
these two do not injure each other,
♦Therefore
their De merges and returns !
[intersects,exchanges,mixes]
Notes
A : compare this line to
the first two lines of the previous chapter and it is easy to see why there
has long been speculation that this line should end the previous chapter;
however, there is an explicit end-of-chapter marker in GUO #59, and GUO does
not even contain this chapter; essentially this line is saying it is easy
to ruin a small fish by overcooking, and it is easy to ruin a nation by
over-controlling
B : first – the “it” is
literal, presumably meaning “the world’s ghosts”; second – “ghosts” is
the most literal, general term, but this could also be referring to demons
(or possibly to souls of the ancestors); third – “spirit” might be better
thought of in this chapter as “spiritual power”, thus this line seems to
be saying that ghosts do not have any power in the world; this and the
next few lines can be translated in many different ways, due to the multiple
meanings of the symbols for “ghost” and “spirit”, and the lack of any
reasonable context – perhaps these lines were addressing some lost ancient
scholarly debate or common cultural belief?
Cross-references
no harm : #35, #56, #58,
#66, #81
returning : #14, #16, #19,
#20, #22, #25, #28, #34, #40,
#52, #58, #64, #65, #80
De and returning :
#28, #65
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account