Darwin, and After Darwin, Volume 2 of 3: Post-Darwinian Questions: Heredity and UtilityRomanes, George John
Science
Darwin, and After Darwin, Volume 2 of 3: Post-Darwinian Questions: Heredity and Utility
Romanes, George John
Evolution (Biology); Heredity
Surely comment is needless. Have the colour of external organs and
integuments nothing to do with the determining of specific distinctions
by systematists? Or, may we not rather ask, are there any other
"characters" which have had more to do with their delineation of animal
species? Therefore, if "the external organs and integuments naturally
give rise to a greater variety of colours," for non-utilitarian reasons,
than is the case with internal organs and tissues; while even the latter
present, for similarly non-utilitarian reasons, such variety and
intensity of colours as they do; must it not follow that, on the ground
of the "Laws of Growth" alone, Mr. Wallace has conceded the entire case
as regards "a large proportional number of specific characters" being
non-adaptive--"spontaneous" in their occurrence, and "meaningless" in
their persistence?
Once more:--
"The enormously lengthened plumes of the bird of paradise and of
the peacock, can, however, have no such use [i.e. for purposes of
defence], but must be rather injurious than beneficial in the
birds' ordinary life. The fact that they have been developed to so
great an extent in a few species is an indication of such perfect
adaptation to the conditions of existence, such complete success in
the battle for life, that there is, in the adult male at all
events, a surplus of strength, vitality, and growth-power, which is
able to expend itself in this way without injury. That such is the
case is shown by the great abundance of most of the species which
possess these wonderful superfluities of plumage.... Why, in allied
species, the development of accessory plumes has taken different
forms, we are unable to say, except that it may be due to that
individual variability which has served as a starting-point for so
much of what seems to us strange in form, or fantastic in colour,
both in the animal and vegetable world[136]."
[136] _Darwinism_, pp. 292-3.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account