Darwin, and After Darwin, Volume 2 of 3: Post-Darwinian Questions: Heredity and UtilityRomanes, George John
Science
Darwin, and After Darwin, Volume 2 of 3: Post-Darwinian Questions: Heredity and Utility
Romanes, George John
Evolution (Biology); Heredity
"The naked skin on the head of a vulture is generally considered as
a direct adaptation for wallowing in putridity; and so it may be,
_or it may possibly be due to the direct action of the putrid
matter_; but we should be very cautious in drawing any such
inference [i.e. as to utility] when we see the skin on the head of
the clean-feeding male Turkey is likewise naked[158]."
[157] _Ibid._
[158] _Origin of Species_, pp. 157-8.
Similarly, in the _Descent of Man_ it is said:--
"Variations of the same _general_ nature have _often been taken
advantage of_ and accumulated through sexual selection in relation
to the propagation of the species, and through natural selection in
relation to the general purposes of life. Hence, _secondary sexual
characters, when equally transmitted to both sexes, can be
distinguished from ordinary specific characters, only by the light
of analogy_. The modifications acquired through sexual selection
are often so strongly pronounced that the two sexes have frequently
been ranked as distinct species, or even as distinct genera[159]."
[159] _Descent of Man_, p. 615.
As Mr. Wallace does not recognize sexual selection, he incurs the burden
of proving utility (in the life-preserving sense) in all these
"frequently" occurring cases where there are such "strongly pronounced
modifications," and we have already seen in the text his manner of
dealing with this burden. But the point here is, that whether or not we
accept the theory of sexual selection, we must accept it as Darwin's
opinion--first, that in their beginnings, as _specific_ characters,
these sexual modifications were often of a merely "_general nature_" (or
without reference to utility even in the life-embellishing sense), and
only _afterwards_ "have often been taken advantage of and accumulated
through _sexual_ selection": and, secondly, that "we know they have been
acquired in some instances _at the cost not only of inconvenience, but
of exposure to actual dangers_[160]."
[160] _Ibid._
We may now pass on to some further, and even stronger, expressions of
opinion with regard to the frequent inutility of _specific_ characters.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account