Deductions from the World WarFreytag-Loringhoven, Hugo Friedrich Philipp Johann, Freiherr von
History
Deductions from the World War
Freytag-Loringhoven, Hugo Friedrich Philipp Johann, Freiherr von
Germany. Heer; War; World War, 1914-1918
In any case the masses, as such, can never rule. If mob-rule is
consequently an absurdity in a State, how much more so is it in an
army. The army which Russia now proclaims to be a national army is
by no means efficient for purposes of war. The words of Treitschke
are significant here:
"A Republic is confronted with still more serious difficulties in the
matter of a standing army. All history has shown that such an army,
whose commissioned ranks are imbued with definite class feelings,
will always be monarchically inclined."[16]
Only under the absolute command of a war lord can an army achieve a
really vigorous development. It cannot be emphasised too often what
an immense debt the Prussian army--and therewith all Germany--owes to
the Prussian Kings.
Napoleon declared, when he was at St. Helena: "Armies are monarchical
through and through."[17] This had been clearly exhibited in his own
army, above all in the Imperial Guard, and in the spirit which
animated the latter. The achievements of the French army under their
great Emperor, and, equally so, those of the last world war, rested
on a surer foundation than the _Spectateur Militaire_, with its empty
phrase-mongering, was willing to admit, when it declared at the
beginning of the sixties of last century[18]:
"The French soldier sees in all his officers, from the sub-lieutenant
to the marshal, merely his equals; he has the clear and certain
conviction that he is inferior to them only in military rank.
Neither training nor education nor birth produces an essential
difference between them. The sense of equality is so strong that the
sense of the ego completely disappears under the absolute domination
of the law of discipline. To what enemy could such soldiers be
inferior? What human might could successfully resist such soldiers
as these, soldiers who stand on an equality with their officers and
who are all heroes?"
This is an instance of that thoroughly French notion of the supreme
blessing of equality. How little it really signifies, and how far it
is from being equivalent to freedom, has been demonstrated by the
World War. Instead of a truly liberal State, we see in the French
Republic a country enslaved by a plutocracy and governed by the
arbitrary will of its English ally. Moreover, every army should
esteem itself fortunate in possessing its own particular notion of
discipline. We have in any case had sufficient experience of the
blessings which our own discipline brings in its train to the welfare
of the German Fatherland, and we intend to hold fast to it in the
future.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account