Either a sinner must repent or he will be damned.
.'. Either a sinner must repent or he will not be saved.
§ 721. _Conversion by Negation of Complex Propositions._
(A) If A is B, C is always D.
.'. If C is not-D, A is never B. (E)
(E) If A is B, C is never D.
.'. If C is D, A is always not-B. (A)
(I) If A is B, C is sometimes D.
.'. If C is D, A is sometimes not not-B. (O)
(O) If A is B, C is sometimes not D.
.'. If C is not-D, A is sometimes B. (I)
(E per acc.) If A is B, C is never D.
.'. If C is not-D, A is sometimes B. (I)
(A per ace.) If A is B, C is always D.
.'. If C is D, A is sometimes not not-D. (O)
§ 722.
(A) If a man is a smoker, he always drinks.
.'. If a man is a total abstainer, he never smokes. (E)
(E) If a man merely does his duty, no one ever thanks him.
.'. If people thank a man, he has always done more than his
duty. (A)
(I) If a statesman is patriotic, he sometimes adheres to a party.
.'. If a statesman adheres to a party, he is sometimes not
unpatriotic. (O)
(O) If a book has merit, it sometimes does not sell.
.'. If a book fails to sell, it sometimes has merit. (I)
(E per acc.) If the wind is high, rain never falls.
.'. If rain falls, the wind is sometimes high. (I)
(A per acc.) If a thing is common, it is always cheap.
.'. If a thing is cheap, it is sometimes not uncommon. (O)
§ 723. When applied to disjunctive propositions, the distinctive
features of conversion by negation are still discernible. In each of
the following forms of inference the converse differs in quality from
the convertend and has the contradictory of one of the original terms
(§ 515).
§ 724.
(A) Either A is B or C is always D.
.'. Either C is D or A is never not-B. (E)
(E) Either A is B or C is never D.
.'. Either C is not-D or A is always B. (A)
(I) Either A is B or C is sometimes D.
.'. Either C is not-D or A is sometimes not B. (O)
(O) Either A is B or C is sometimes not D.
.'. Either C is D or A is sometimes not-B. (I)
§ 725.
(A) Either miracles are possible or every ancient historian is
untrustworthy.
.'. Either ancient historians are untrustworthy or miracles are
not impossible. (E)
(E) Either the tide must turn or the vessel can not make the port.
.'. Either the vessel cannot make the port or the tide must
turn. (A)
(1) Either he aims too high or the cartridges are sometimes bad.
.'. Either the cartridges are not bad or he sometimes does not
aim too high. (0)
(O) Either care must be taken or telegrams will sometimes not be
correct.
.'. Either telegrams are correct or carelessness is sometimes
shown. (1)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account