(1) All Devonshire men are Englishmen.
All Bideford men are Devonshire men.
.'. All Bideford men are Englishmen.
(2) All Englishmen are Teutons.
All Bideford men are Englishmen.
.'. All Bideford men are Teutons.
(3) All Teutons are Aryans.
All Bideford men are Teutons.
.'. All Bideford men are Aryans.
_Regressive Sorites._
All Teutons are Aryans.
All Englishmen are Teutons.
All Devonshiremen are Englishmen.
All Bideford men are Devonshiremen.
.'. All Bideford men are Aryans.
(1) All Teutons are Aryans.
All Englishmen are Teutons.
.'. All Englishmen are Aryans.
(2) All Englishmen are Aryans.
All Devonshiremen are Englishmen.
.'. All Devonshiremen are Aryans.
(3) All Devonshiremen are Aryans.
All Bideford men are Devonshiremen.
.'. All Bideford men are Aryans.
§ 816. When expanded, the sorites is found to contain as many
syllogisms as there are propositions intermediate between the first
and the last. This is evident also on inspection by counting the
number of middle terms.
§ 817. In expanding the progressive form we have to commence with the
second proposition of the sorites as the major premiss of the first
syllogism. In the progressive form the subject of the conclusion is
the same in all the syllogisms; in the regressive form the predicate
is the same. In both the same series of means, or middle terms, is
employed, the difference lying in the extremes that are compared with
one another through them.
[Illustration]
§ 818. It is apparent from the figure that in the progressive form we
work from within outwards, in the regressive form from without
inwards. In the former we first employ the term 'Devonshiremen' as a
mean to connect 'Bideford men' with 'Englishmen'; next we employ
'Englishmen' as a mean to connect the same subject 'Bideford men' with
the wider term 'Teutons'; and, lastly, we employ 'Teutons' as a mean
to connect the original subject 'Bideford men' with the ultimate
predicate 'Ayrans.'
§ 819. Reversely, in the regressive form we first use 'Teutons' as a
mean whereby to bring 'Englishmen' under 'Aryans'; next we use
'Englishmen' as a mean whereby to bring 'Devonshiremen' under the dame
predicate 'Aryans'; and, lastly, we use 'Devonshiremen' as a mean
whereby to bring the ultimate subject 'Bideford men' under the
original predicate 'Aryans.'
§ 820. A sorites may be either Regular or Irregular.
§ 821. In the regular form the terms which connect each proposition in
the series with its predecessor, that is to say, the middle terms,
maintain a fixed relative position; so that, if the middle term be
subject in one, it will always be predicate in the other, and vice
versâ. In the irregular form this symmetrical arrangement is violated.
§ 822. The syllogisms which compose a regular sorites, whether
progressive or regressive, will always be in the first figure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account