Defense of the Faith and the Saints (Volume 1 of 2)Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Religion
Defense of the Faith and the Saints (Volume 1 of 2)
Roberts, B. H. (Brigham Henry)
Latter Day Saint churches
I shall at this point read to you the synopsis of the reverend
gentleman's discourse; and while the synopsis cannot be so satisfactory
as the whole discourse would be, still I think likely he has mentioned
his chief objections to the book in the synopsis, as I am informed that
he himself prepared it for the public press; so that what I quote is
his own representation of the discourse, and doubtless contains all the
points he scored against our III Nephi.
SYNOPSIS OF DR. PADEN'S DISCOURSE.
"'Gospels Apocryphal and Real,' was the title of Dr. William M.
Paden's sermon last night. It was in a way a continuation of his
sermons on the book of Nephi, and again a large congregation
assembled to hear him. He first gave an account of the apocryphal
gospels of the infancy, Nicodemus, the birth of the virgin, and
others. These he compared and classed with the gospel according
to Nephi, which he had explained and dealt with the two preceding
Sundays. Much in these so-called gospels anyone could quote or
gather from the real gospels; the greater part of the rest of the
matter, of the rest that is not [so] copied, anyone could write.
After this Dr. Paden went on to speak of the manner in which our
real gospels added something of real worth to the pictures of
Christ. Thus Matthew improved on Mark, Luke on Matthew and Mark,
and John on them all. Does III Nephi add anything worth while to
the picture? he asked. Luke gives us the story of the prodigal,
John the story of the good Samaritan. Matthew has given us many
parables. What does Nephi add which deserves to be classed with
such revelations? How does it come that this so-called fifth gospel
gives us no new parables? One real, original parable of the class
that is found in the gospel according to Matthew would give it the
necessary standing. One grand new chapter like the 15th of Luke,
or the 3rd of John, would be as great a surprise in this gospel
according to Nephi as a Psalm like the 23rd would be in the early
part of the Book of Mormon.
"Concerning the authenticity of the would-be fifth gospel, Dr.
Paden made use of a very appropriate and telling simile. He said
the question is not where do men say they got it, but, is it gold?
These four nuggets, (i. e., the four Hebrew gospels), are gold. If
your supposed nugget is not, it matters little where you got it;
your father and grandfather may have been mistaken--you must submit
to the gold test."
THE QUESTION STATED.
You will observe that the primary consideration in the reverend
gentleman's discourse is, Does III Nephi add anything to the picture of
Christ? Is our Christian knowledge increased by it? It is that question
that I propose to consider.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account